A Litigator's Guide to DNA educates both criminal law students and forensic science students about all aspects of the use of DNA evidence in criminal and civil trials. It includes discussions of the molecular biological basis for the tests, essential laboratory practices, probability theory and mathematical calculations, and issues relevant to the prosecution and the defense, and to the judge and jury hearing the case.
The authors provide a full background on both the molecular biology and the mathematical theory behind forensic tests, describing the molecular biological process in simple mechanical terms that are familiar to everyone, and periodically emphasizing the practical, take-home messages the student truly needs to understand.
Pedagogical elements such as Recapping the Main Point boxes and valuable ancillary material (Instructors' Manual, PowerPoint slides) make this an ideal text for professors.
- "Recapping the Main Point" boxes provide a simple and concise summary of the main points
- Includes a glossary of essential terms and their definitions
- Contains a full-color insert with illustrations that emphasize key concepts
Inhaltsverzeichnis
1;Cover;1 2;Dedication;6 3;Table of Contents;8 4;ACKNOWLEDGMENTS;12 5;INTRODUCTION;14 6;CHAPTER 1 The Structure of DNA and the Variability of the Human DNA Sequence;16 6.1;You Are Out of Your Field, But Not Out of Your Depth;16 6.2;Markers, Alleles, Genotypes and Profiles;17 6.3;The Two Sources of DNA in Human Cells;20 6.4;The Structure of DNA and RNA;21 6.5;Variability Is the Rule, Not the Exception;26 6.6;Polymorphisms Commonly Used for Forensic Testing;30 6.7;Using the DNA Profile to Identify an Unknown Perpetrator;39 6.8;References and Additional Readings;40 7;CHAPTER 2 The Molecular Biological Basis of Forensic DNA Tests;42 7.1;Extraction and Quantification of DNA;42 7.2;Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR)-Based Tests;47 7.3;Variable Number of Tandem Repeats (VNTR) Testing;65 7.4;Direct Sequencing;66 7.5;References and Additional Readings;68 8;CHAPTER 3 Quality Control, Quality Assurance and Sources of Uncertainty in the Data;70 8.1;Laboratory Accreditation, Personnel Certification and Proficiency Testing;70 8.2;Validation Studies;74 8.3;The Inevitable Nemeses: Suboptimal Samples and Human Error;76 8.4;Allele Dropout Due to Degradation, Preferential Amplification and Stochastic Effects;85 8.5;Artifacts Inherent in STR Analyses;90 8.6;Hybridization Specificity in Dot-Blot Tests;102 8.7;References and Additional Readings;103 9;CHAPTER 4 Population Genetics, Probability Calculations and the Proper Interpretation of the Evidence;106 9.1;The Common Logical Fallacies;106 9.2;Databanks and Databases;114 9.3;Allele Frequencies, Genotype Probabilities and the Product Rule for Independent Events;121 9.4;The Principles of Population Genetics that Impact Forensic DNA Calculations;128 9.5;Applying the Product RuleCompensating for Population Substructure and Possible Allele Dropout;134 9.6;The Likelihood Ratio (LR) Allows the Analyst to Compare the Strength of Competing Hypotheses;150 9.7;The Application of Bayes Theorem to Paternity Disputes;157 9.8;Recommended Procedure for An
alyzing Mixed Samples;162 9.9;References and Additional Readings;182 10;CHAPTER 5 Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) Analyses;186 10.1;The mtDNA MoleculeAbundant and Durable but Less Variable than nDNA;186 10.2;Laboratory Analysis of mtDNA Haplotypes;189 10.3;Matrilineal Inheritance and a Lack of Recombination;193 10.4;A High Mutation Rate Leads to Mitochondrial Heteroplasmy;195 10.5;Statistical Analysis of mtDNA Haplotype Data;202 10.6;References and Additional Readings;208 11;CHAPTER 6 Y Chromosome Analyses;212 11.1;Y Chromosome Evolution and its Consequences for Forensic Analyses;212 11.2;Laboratory Analysis of Y Chromosome Haplotypes;219 11.3;Statistical Analysis of Y Chromosome Haplotypes;222 11.4;References and Additional Readings;227 12;CHAPTER 7 DNA in Court;230 12.1;The Evolution of Standards for Admissibility of Experts and Evidence;230 12.2;The Ongoing Controversy Regarding Laboratory Error Rates;240 12.3;Counsels Obligations Regarding Discovery;243 12.4;Expert Witnesses;247 12.5;The Durability of DNA Presents Problems for Statutes of Limitation;252 12.6;Rape Shield Laws May Limit the Use of DNA Evidence;253 12.7;Judges and Jurors Perceptions of DNA Evidence;254 12.8;References and Additional Readings;268 13;CHAPTER 8 Arguing for the Prosecution;270 13.1;Obtaining DNA Samples;270 13.2;DNA in the Courtroom: The Essentials of the Prosecutions Presentation;294 13.3;References and Additional Readings;327 14;CHAPTER 9 Arguing for the Defense;328 14.1;The Defenses Choice of Strategy;328 14.2;Elements of a Competent Defense;341 14.3;When the Defendant Has Been Identified by a Databank Search;377 14.4;References and Additional Readings;382 15;CHAPTER 10 Postconviction DNA Testing;384 15.1;DNA has the Power to Exonerate the Innocent;384 15.2;Avenues for Relief;385 15.3;There Are Many Procedural Obstacles;388 15.4;New Evidence May Justify a New Theory of the Case;394 15.5;Accessing the Necessary Samples;395 15.6;Know the Specific Provisions of the Controlling Statute;398 15
.7;References and Additional Readings;401 16;APPENDIX I: Using the Chi-Square Test to Determine if a Population Conforms to HWE Expectations;404 17;APPENDIX II: How the RMP, Prior Odds of Guilt, and the PFP Influence the Posterior Odds of Guilt (POG);408 18;APPENDIX III: Paternity Index (PI) Calculations for Different Combinations of Maternal, Child and Alleged Father Genotypes;412 19;APPENDIX IV: A Sample Consent Form to Collect an Oral Swab, Which Allows the Profile Obtained to Be Entered Into a Databank for Use in Additional;414 20;APPENDIX V: Doing Your Own Research: Useful References, Websites and Strategies for Finding Current Information;416 21;GLOSSARY OF KEY TERMS;426 22;INDEX;438 23;Color Plates;446