Microbial Forensics is a rapidly evolving scientific discipline. In the last decade, and particularly due to the anthrax letter attacks in the United States, microbial forensics has become more formalized and has played an increasingly greater role in crime investigations. This has brought renewed interest, development and application of new technologies, and new rules of forensic and policy engagement. It has many applications ranging from biodefense, criminal investigations, providing intelligence information, making society more secure, and helping protect precious resources, particularly human life. A combination of diverse areas is investigated, including the major disciplines of biology, microbiology, medicine, chemistry, physics, statistics, population genetics, and computer science.
Microbial Forensics, Second Edition is fully revised and updated and serves as a complete reference of the discipline. It describes the advances, as well as the challenges and opportunities ahead, and will be integral in applying science to help solve future biocrimes.
- A collection of microbiology, virology, toxicology and mycology as it relates to forensics, in one reference
- New and expanded content to include statistical analysis of forensic data and legal admissibility and the standards of evidence, to name a few
- Includes research information and application of that research to crime scene analysis, which will allow practitioners to understand and apply the knowledge to their practice with ease
Inhaltsverzeichnis
1;FRONT COVER;1 2;MICROBIAL FORENSICS;4 3;COPYRIGHT PAGE;5 4;CONTENTS;6 5;CONTRIBUTORS;10 6;FOREWORD;16 7;ACKNOWLEDGMENTS;18 8;INTRODUCTION The Rapidly Evolving Discipline of Microbial Forensics;20 9;PART 1 INVESTIGATIVE GENETICS;24 9.1;Section A: Criminal;26 9.1.1;CHAPTER 1 The Kameido Anthrax Incident: A Microbial Forensics Case Study;28 9.1.1.1;Introduction;28 9.1.1.2;The Aum Shinrikyo: A Brief History;28 9.1.1.3;The Kameido Anthrax Incident;31 9.1.1.4;Microbial Forensics Investigation;32 9.1.1.5;Epidemiological Investigation;33 9.1.1.6;Discussion;34 9.1.1.7;Challenges;35 9.1.1.8;References;36 9.1.2;CHAPTER 2 Microbial Forensic Investigation of the Anthrax-Letter Attacks;38 9.1.2.1;The Anthrax-Letter Event;38 9.1.2.2;Identifying the Attack Strain;41 9.1.2.3;Whole Genome Sequencing of the Florida Ames Strain;42 9.1.2.4;Development of Ames-Specific Assays;43 9.1.2.5;The FBI Repository;43 9.1.2.6;Morphological Variants;44 9.1.2.7;Conclusion and Remaining Issues;46 9.1.2.8;References;47 9.2;Section B: Civilian;50 9.2.1;CHAPTER 3 Food-Borne Outbreaks: Whats New, Whats Not, and Where Do We Go from Here?;52 9.2.1.1;Prologue;52 9.2.1.2;Food-borne Illness: an Old but Persistent Problem;53 9.2.1.3;The Changing Landscape of Food-Borne Outbreaks;54 9.2.1.4;Enteric Pathogens as Bioterrorism Agents;57 9.2.1.5;Epilogue;60 9.2.1.6;References;61 9.2.2;CHAPTER 4 Genotype and Geography: The Global Distribution of Bovine Tuberculosis;66 9.2.2.1;What Can Bacterial Genotyping Offer the Forensic Microbiologist?;66 9.2.2.2;Has This Strain Been Recently Imported?;67 9.2.2.3;Where Did This Strain Come From?;68 9.2.2.4;Bovine Tuberculosis;68 9.2.2.5;Geographical Localization of M. Bovis Genotypes in Great Britain;69 9.2.2.6;Bovine Tuberculosis in the British Isles;70 9.2.2.7;Global Distribution of M. Bovis Genotypes;71 9.2.2.8;Europe 1A Globally Important Clonal Complex of M. Bovis;72 9.2.2.9;African 1Dominant in West-Central Africa;74 9.2.2.10;African 2Dominant in East Africa;76 9.2.2.11;
Other Clonal Complexes of M. Bovis in Africa;76 9.2.2.12;Of What Use Is A Baby?;77 9.2.2.13;Can We Identify the Origin of Imported Strains?;78 9.2.2.14;Acknowledgment;78 9.2.2.15;References;78 9.2.3;CHAPTER 5 Tracing Meat Products through the Production and Distribution Chain from Farm to Consumer;82 9.2.3.1;Introduction;82 9.2.3.2;Meat Chain Structure and Complexity;82 9.2.3.3;Genetic Identification of the Host Animal and its Derived Products;85 9.2.3.4;Tracing Meat Products Through the Supply Chain;87 9.2.3.5;Washington State BSE-Positive Cow;90 9.2.3.6;Food Safety;93 9.2.3.7;Practical Limits;93 9.2.3.8;Summary and Future Directions;95 9.2.3.9;References;95 9.2.4;CHAPTER 6 Microbial Forensics of RNA Viruses: Foot-and-Mouth Disease Virus;98 9.2.4.1;Challenges Posed by RNA Viruses;98 9.2.4.2;A Case Study: Foot-and-Mouth Disease in the United Kingdom (2001);99 9.2.4.3;What Information is Needed;100 9.2.4.4;Where We are Now;103 9.2.4.5;What Needs to be Done;104 9.2.4.6;References;107 9.2.5;CHAPTER 7 Forensic Plant Pathology;112 9.2.5.1;Introduction;112 9.2.5.2;Naturally Caused Versus Intentional Introduction?;113 9.2.5.3;History of Agricultural Bioweapons;113 9.2.5.4;The Need for Forensic Plant Pathology;115 9.2.5.5;Pathogen Detection and Diagnostics;116 9.2.5.6;Epidemiology in Forensic Investigation;117 9.2.5.7;Mutation, Evolution, and Forensic Plant Pathology;118 9.2.5.8;Investigation;120 9.2.5.9;Roles and Responsibilities;121 9.2.5.10;Education and Outreach;123 9.2.5.11;Resources and Infrastructure;124 9.2.5.12;Gaps;125 9.2.5.13;Summary;126 9.2.5.14;References;126 10;PART 2 EMERGING INFECTIONS;130 10.1;CHAPTER 8 Influenza Forensics;132 10.1.1;Introduction;132 10.1.2;The Influenza Virus;133 10.1.3;Influenza a Genomics;133 10.1.4;Influenza Nomenclature;136 10.1.5;Time: The Major Foe of Influenza Forensics;139 10.1.6;A Brief History of Pandemic Influenza a in Humans;140 10.1.7;2009 H1N1 Pandemic;142 10.1.8;Outbreak Detection: Symptoms, Diagnostics, and Surveillance;14
5 10.1.9;Surveillance;147 10.1.10;Diagnostics;147 10.1.11;Influenza as a Bioweapon;149 10.1.12;Moving Forward;152 10.1.13;Acknowledgments;152 10.1.14;References;152 10.2;CHAPTER 9 Keeping Track of Viruses;160 10.2.1;Introduction;160 10.2.2;What is a Virus?;160 10.2.3;Virus Life Cycle;161 10.2.4;How Do You Identify A Virus?;163 10.2.5;Viral Diversity and Phylogenetics;169 10.2.6;Solving a Biocrime;171 10.2.7;Challenges That Remain;174 10.2.8;Acknowledgments;174 10.2.9;References;175 10.3;CHAPTER 10 Microbial Forensic Analysis of Trace and Unculturable Specimens;178 10.3.1;Introduction to Bioforensic Analysis of Trace DNA;178 10.3.2;Use of WGA for Microbial Forensic Analysis of Trace Environmental Specimens;181 10.3.3;Deep Sequence Analysis of Bacillus anthracis Sterne Strain by Roche 454 Genome Sequencing Technology;185 10.3.4;Microbial Forensic Sequence Analysis of Trace Specimens of Bacillus anthracis by Single Molecule Real-Time Sequencing;188 10.3.5;Conclusions and Remaining Challenges;191 10.3.6;Acknowledgments;192 10.3.7;References;192 10.4;CHAPTER 11 Molecular Microbial Surveillance and Discovery in Bioforensics;196 10.4.1;Fundamental Questions: What is it? How Did it Get There? What Can We do About it? Climate is What You Expect; Weather is What You GetHow Expectations;196 10.4.2;Characterization of the Threat: What Kind of Bug is It?;198 10.4.3;Conclusion;204 10.4.4;Acknowledgments;204 10.4.5;References;205 11;PART 3 BIOSECURITY;210 11.1;CHAPTER 12 Assessment of the Threat;212 11.1.1;National Threat Assessment: Role of the Intelligence Community;212 11.1.2;Threat Credibility Assessments: Role of Law Enforcement and Public Health Officials;215 11.1.3;Conclusion;219 11.1.4;References;219 11.2;CHAPTER 13 Select Agent Regulations;222 11.2.1;Introduction;222 11.2.2;The Select Agent Regulations;229 11.2.3;Summary;241 11.2.4;Acknowledgments;242 11.2.5;References;242 11.3;CHAPTER 14 Biosurety in the Post-9/11 Era;244 11.3.1;Introduction: Amerithrax and the Focus on
Biosurety;244 11.3.2;The Threat of Misuse of Biological Agents;245 11.3.3;Categories of Threats;248 11.3.4;The Challenge of Protecting Against Insider Threats;252 11.3.5;Conclusion;258 11.3.6;References;259 11.4;CHAPTER 15 Forensic Public Health: Epidemiologic and Microbiologic Investigations for Biosecurity;262 11.4.1;Introduction;262 11.4.2;Dynamics of Disease Transmission;262 11.4.3;Outbreak Investigation;264 11.4.4;Deliberate Introduction of a Biological Agent;265 11.4.5;Molecular Strain Typing;269 11.4.6;Summary;275 11.4.7;Acknowledgments;276 11.4.8;References;276 12;PART 4 SUBJECT AREAS;280 12.1;CHAPTER 16 Forensic Analysis in Bacterial Pathogens;282 12.1.1;Introduction;282 12.1.2;16S Sequences and Rapid Identification of Microbes;283 12.1.3;Forensic Signatures: Human Versus Bacterial Pathogens;283 12.1.4;Bacillus Anthracis: A Model System;284 12.1.5;Mutation Rates in Bacteria;286 12.1.6;Yersinia Pestis and Plague: Another Recently Emerged Pathogen;287 12.1.7;Francisella Tularensis;289 12.1.8;Brucella spp. and Brucellosis;290 12.1.9;Burkholderia Pseudomallei;292 12.1.10;Clostridium Botulinum;293 12.1.11;Conclusions;295 12.1.12;References;295 12.2;CHAPTER 17 Rickettsia and Coxiella;300 12.2.1;Introduction;300 12.2.2;Rocky Mountain Spotted Fever, Epidemic Typhus, and Q Fever: The Diseases;301 12.2.3;Epidemiology;302 12.2.4;Diagnosis/Detection in Clinical Samples;303 12.2.5;Detection in Environmental Samples;304 12.2.6;Rickettsia Strain Typing;305 12.2.7;Coxiella Strain Typing;308 12.2.8;Conclusions;310 12.2.9;References;310 12.3;CHAPTER 18 Forensics and Epidemiology of Fungal Pathogens;320 12.3.1;Introduction;320 12.3.2;The Kingdom Fungi;320 12.3.3;Pathogenic Fungi;321 12.3.4;Conclusions;333 12.3.5;Disclaimer;333 12.3.6;References;334 12.4;CHAPTER 19 Ricin Forensics: Comparisons to Microbial Forensics;338 12.4.1;Introduction;338 12.4.2;Background;339 12.4.3;Ricin Toxin Detection;342 12.4.4;Castor Bean Genotyping;344 12.4.5;Challenges;346 12.4.6;References;347 12
.5;CHAPTER 20 Forensic Aspects of Biological Toxins;350 12.5.1;Introduction;350 12.5.2;Botulinum Neurotoxin and Botulism;350 12.5.3;Ricin;365 12.5.4;Staphylococcal Enterotoxin B;366 12.5.5;Clostridium Perfringens Epsilon Toxin;367 12.5.6;Summary;367 12.5.7;Acknowledgment;368 12.5.8;References;368 13;PART 5 METHODS;378 13.1;CHAPTER 21 Use of Host Factors in Microbial Forensics;380 13.1.1;Introduction and Background;380 13.1.2;General Concepts;382 13.1.3;Illustrative Concepts;385 13.1.4;Utility of Serologic Analysis of People Exposed to Anthrax: Strengths and Limitations;387 13.1.5;Considerations and Concerns Raised by Analysis of Other Infections;391 13.1.6;Possible Scenarios of Bioterrorism Attacks: Distinguishing Victims from Perpetrators;395 13.1.7;References;398 13.2;CHAPTER 22 Collection and Preservation of Microbial Forensic Samples;402 13.2.1;General Best Practices of Collection of Forensic Evidence;404 13.2.2;Collection Strategies and Methods for Microbial Forensic Sampling;407 13.2.3;Looking to the Future;411 13.2.4;References;412 13.3;CHAPTER 23 Sampling for Microbial Forensic Investigations;416 13.3.1;Introduction;416 13.3.2;Commonalties and Differences Between Microbial Epidemiological and Microbial Forensic Investigations;417 13.3.3;Problems Associated with Sampling Activities for Both Microbial Epidemiological and Microbial Forensic Investigations;418 13.3.4;Challenges for Microbial Epidemiological and Microbial Forensic Investigations;423 13.3.5;Conclusion;425 13.3.6;Disclaimer;425 13.3.7;References;426 13.4;CHAPTER 24 Toxin Analysis Using Mass Spectrometry;428 13.4.1;Introduction;428 13.4.2;Specific Analytical Methods for Toxins;435 13.4.3;Quality Control, Validation, and Data Review;439 13.4.4;Current Limitations to Toxin Analysis;440 13.4.5;References;441 13.5;CHAPTER 25 Electron Beam-Based Methods for Bioforensic Investigations;444 13.5.1;Introduction;444 13.5.2;Electron Beam-Based Characterization Techniques;445 13.5.3;Conventional and Advanced Me
thods of Microanalysis, Data Acquisition and Analysis;454 13.5.4;Sample Preparation for Sem and (S)Tem;458 13.5.5;Applications of Electron Beam Characterization in Bioforensics;462 13.5.6;Summary;467 13.5.7;Acknowledgments;469 13.5.8;References;469 13.6;CHAPTER 26 Proteomics Development and Application for Bioforensics;472 13.6.1;Introduction;472 13.6.2;Microbiology and Biochemistry;473 13.6.3;Protein Detection and IdentificationMass Spectrometry for Proteomics Analysis;475 13.6.4;Computational Sciences;477 13.6.5;Summary;479 13.6.6;References;480 13.7;CHAPTER 27 High-Throughput Sequencing;484 13.7.1;Initial DNA Sequencing Approaches;484 13.7.2;Microbial Genome Sequencing;486 13.7.3;Next-Generation Sequencing Technology;490 13.7.4;Assembly Methods for DNA Sequence;495 13.7.5;Resequencing;497 13.7.6;Conclusion;497 13.7.7;References;498 13.8;CHAPTER 28 Genomics;502 13.8.1;Sequencing Technologies;503 13.8.2;Bioinformatics Sequence Analysis;506 13.8.3;The Pregenomic Era;507 13.8.4;Comparative Genomics;508 13.8.5;High-Throughput Screening Assays;509 13.8.6;Metagenomics;510 13.8.7;Genome Architecture and Evolution;510 13.8.8;Future Challenges;511 13.8.9;Genomics and Microbial Forensics;512 13.8.10;References;513 13.9;CHAPTER 29 Design of Genomic Signatures for Pathogen Identification and Characterization;516 13.9.1;Genomic Signatures;516 13.9.2;Different Types and Resolutions of Genomic Signatures;517 13.9.3;Potential Target Organisms;517 13.9.4;Signature Resolution;518 13.9.5;Genomic Sequence Data: What To Use And Where To Get It;518 13.9.6;Identifying Conserved Sequence Among Targets;520 13.9.7;Identifying Sequences Unique to Targets;521 13.9.8;Mining for Signatures;522 13.9.9;How Kpath Signatures are Designed;522 13.9.10;RNA Viruses Present Additional Challenges;523 13.9.11;Signatures of Potential Bacterial Genetic Engineering;525 13.9.12;Viral and Bacterial Detection Array;527 13.9.13;The Future of Genomic Signatures;528 13.9.14;Disclaimer;530 13.9.15;References;530 1
3.10;CHAPTER 30 Nonbiological Measurements on Biological Agents;532 13.10.1;Introduction;532 13.10.2;Determining Manufacturing Method;533 13.10.3;Sample Matching;539 13.10.4;Remaining Research and Development Challenges;541 13.10.5;Preparing for Future Events;544 13.10.6;Concluding Remarks;545 13.10.7;Acknowledgments;545 13.10.8;Disclaimer;546 13.10.9;References;546 13.11;CHAPTER 31 Inferential Validation and Evidence Interpretation;550 13.11.1;The Need to Validate the Interpretation of Microbial Forensic Evidence;550 13.11.2;The Taxonomy of Validation;551 13.11.3;The ROC/LR Framework for Inferential Validation;554 13.11.4;Application to Chemical and Physical Analysis of Biological Agents;562 13.11.5;Conclusion;565 13.11.6;Disclaimer;565 13.11.7;References;565 13.12;CHAPTER 32 Microbial Forensic Investigations in the Context of Bacterial Population Genetics;568 13.12.1;Introduction and Background;568 13.12.2;A Microbial Forensic Paradigm;571 13.12.3;Calculating Match Probabilities;578 13.12.4;Reference Database;579 13.12.5;Discussion;580 13.12.6;References;581 13.13;CHAPTER 33 Population Genetic Considerations in Statistical Interpretation of Microbial Forensic Data in Comparision with Human DNA Forensic Standard;584 13.13.1;Introduction;584 13.13.2;Background of Some Major Pathogens;585 13.13.3;Statistical Paradigm of Source Attribution of Microbial Agents;586 13.13.4;Conclusions;596 13.13.5;References;597 13.14;CHAPTER 34 Biorepositories and Their FoundationsMicrobial Forensic Considerations;604 13.14.1;Introduction: Role of Biorepositories and Systematics in Microbial Forensics;604 13.14.2;Operational Biorepository Collection Verification and Validation Concerns;608 13.14.3;Beyond MLSTExtended Range Ultraresolution Typing;613 13.14.4;Challenges;615 13.14.5;Acknowledgments;621 13.14.6;References;621 14;PART 6 NATIONAL LEVEL CAPABILITIES;626 14.1;CHAPTER 35 A U.S. Research Strategy for Microbial Forensics: From Genesis to Implementation;628 14.1.1;Introduction;628
14.1.2;The Pillars of Biodefense;630 14.1.3;Setting the Foundation for a Research Strategy;631 14.1.4;Implementing a Formal Government Research Strategy;633 14.1.5;A Comprehensive Microbial Forensic Strategy Emerges;634 14.1.6;Meeting the Research Strategic GoalsMicrobial Forensic Research Program in DHS S&T;637 14.1.7;Conclusion;639 14.1.8;References;640 14.2;CHAPTER 36 The National Bioforensic Analysis Center;642 14.2.1;Introduction;642 14.2.2;History of the NBFAC;642 14.2.3;NBFAC Operational Components;644 14.2.4;NBFAC Biothreat Agent Bioforensic Capability Expansion and Vision for the Future;645 14.2.5;New NBACC Laboratory Building;646 14.2.6;Conclusion;647 14.2.7;References;647 14.3;CHAPTER 37 Microbial Forensics in AustraliaThe Australian Federal Police Perspective;650 14.3.1;Introduction;650 14.3.2;The Threat of Bioterrorism in Australia;652 14.3.3;The Australian CBRN Data Center;652 14.3.4;The Australian Federal Police and its Role in Preventing, Countering, and Investigating Terrorism;653 14.3.5;The Australian Federal Police Microbial Forensics Program;654 14.3.6;The Australian Federal Police Mobile and Triage Laboratories;657 14.3.7;National Regulatory Scheme for Biological Agents of Security Concern;664 14.3.8;Potential Expansions to the Australian Federal Police Microbial Forensic Capability;665 14.3.9;The Australian Federal Police in the Whole of Government Approach to Bioterrorism;665 14.3.10;Conclusion;668 14.3.11;Acknowledgment;669 14.3.12;References;669 14.4;CHAPTER 38 Validation of Microbial Forensics in Scientific, Legal, and Policy Contexts;672 14.4.1;Introduction;672 14.4.2;An Accepted Approach to Validation Exists;673 14.4.3;Validation as Part of the Quest for Quality in Forensic Science;675 14.4.4;Legal Validation of Novel Scientific Techniques in U.S. Courts;676 14.4.5;Observations of the National Academy of Sciences (2009);681 14.4.6;Validation: Science at Intersections of Legal and Policy Environments: Snapshot Illustrations;682 14.4.7;Chal
lenges Ahead for Microbial Forensics;684 14.4.8;Disclaimer;684 14.4.9;References;684 15;PART 7 MICROBIAL FORENSICS CURRICULA AND TRAINING;688 15.1;CHAPTER 39 Microbial Forensics: Educating the Workforce and the Community;690 15.1.1;Microbial Forensics Curricula and Training;691 15.1.2;Basic Epidemiology;694 15.1.3;Molecular Epidemiology;695 15.1.4;Microbes and Their Products as Biological Weapons;695 15.1.5;Host Factors Including Immune Responses;696 15.1.6;Processes and Technology;696 15.1.7;Forensic Science;700 15.1.8;Case Histories;701 15.1.9;Legal Issues;701 15.1.10;Operational and Intelligence Issues;702 15.1.11;National-Level Capabilities and Resources;702 15.1.12;Conclusion;703 15.1.13;References;703 15.2;CHAPTER 40 So You Really Want to Be an Expert Witness? A Primer for the Occasional Expert Witness;704 15.2.1;Attorneys Roles;704 15.2.2;Discovery;706 15.2.3;Experts Roles;709 15.2.4;Consequences of Discovery Violation;710 15.2.5;Grant Solicitations/Applications;711 15.2.6;Peer Review Articles/Comments;712 15.2.7;References;714 15.3;CHAPTER 41 Microbial Forensics, What Next?;716 15.3.1;References;719 16;INDEX;720 16.1;A;720 16.2;B;721 16.3;C;724 16.4;D;725 16.5;E;727 16.6;F;728 16.7;G;729 16.8;H;730 16.9;I;731 16.10;J;733 16.11;K;733 16.12;L;733 16.13;M;733 16.14;N;735 16.15;O;736 16.16;P;736 16.17;Q;738 16.18;R;739 16.19;S;740 16.20;T;743 16.21;U;743 16.22;V;744 16.23;W;745 16.24;X;745 16.25;Y;745 16.26;Z;745 17;COLOR PLATES;746