"This is a superb book. In it Stacy Smith not only tells a compelling story of a school struggling to be a democratic community, but also embeds this account in a philosophically illuminating discussion of the nature of democratic practice. It is one of the few books of which I am aware in which ethnography and philosophy are equal partners and are done with equal competence." (Kenneth Strike, University of Maryland)
"The increasingly contentious debates on charter schools are sorely in need of balanced, thoughtful vision informed by our nation's historical struggles around democracy, public participation, and the common school. Stacy Smith's impressive book achieves all this and more. Dr. Smith asks hard questions, not only of charter schools, but of public schooling in America. Her voice is smart, reasoned, and compelling and her portrait of Winthrop Academy Charter School finally grounds the charter debates in the complex world of teaching, learning, and community-building. At last, thanks to Dr. Smith, key philosophical issues about social reproduction and schooling are placed center stage in our current reform struggles." (Eric Rofes, Humboldt State University)