Documenting the history of a living social movement is a challenge, but this is what Mary Jeremy Daigler has undertaken in Incompatible with God's Design, the first history of the U.S. Roman Catholic women's ordination movement. American Catholic Studies This is a rigorous and thoroughly researched history of the movement that will be required reading for anyone who wants or needs to be informed on our movement as well as a good read. Incompatible with God's Design is a page-turner filled with personal stories and drama and yet it is also balanced with the keen insight and reporting of a seasoned historian... The women's ordination movement owes a great debt of gratitude to Mary Jeremy Daigler for this magnum opus. She has put in writing the definitive story that needed to be told. New Women, New Church As a historical record of the women's ordination movement in the United States, Daigler's latest publication is highly recommended for its fair and balanced treatment of a most controversial subject. This work would be highly appropriate for institutions of higher education, with collections dedicated to church history, feminist studies, and pastoral theology. Catholic Library World [Incompatible with God's Design] is a story of intense dedication, ingenuity, and frustration. Using all the tools of the historical investigator, Mary Jeremy Daigler pieces together the narrative of women in the Roman Catholic Church on a quest for priestly ordination. It is a story that has not been told before... [T]his work is groundbreaking and of great interest. Where Daigler exercises her considerable narrative powers and lets the story speak, discerning eyes can glimpse a whole segment of the Body of Christ struggling to be heard by those in authority. Readers may recognize charismatic individuals whose attempt to act on what they have been taught to believe runs headlong into harsh judgments about their motivations. Women will see throughout how seemingly impossible it is to enter into true dialogue in a Church where women are still considered, in practice, subordinate-no matter how the rhetoric has changed. More's the pity that there cannot be a free and open discussion of the issue in the U.S. Roman Catholic Church. It is an old story made new at the hands of a fine writer. -- Mary Aquin O'Neill, Mount Saint Agnes Theological Center for Women It is heartening to see a...book that documents the many years of work for women's spiritual justice in a world where silence is no longer acceptable...The book...is an integral, one might say "compatible" part of the growing, and ever more accessible media on this controversial and topical exploration of God's design for women religious-and their secular sisters. National Catholic Reporter