In the last twenty years considerable progress has been made in process risk and reliability management, particularly in regard to regulatory compliance. Many companies are now looking to go beyond mere compliance; they are expanding their process safety management (PSM) programs to improve performance not just in safety, but also in environmental compliance, quality control and overall profitability. Techniques and principles are illustrated with numerous examples from chemical plants, refineries, transportation, pipelines and offshore oil and gas.
This book helps executives, managers and technical professionals achieve not only their current PSM goals, but also to make the transition to a broader operational integrity strategy. The book focuses on the energy and process industries- from refineries, to pipelines, chemical plants, transportation, energy and offshore facilities. The techniques described in the book can also be applied to a wide range of non-process industries.
The book is both thorough and practical. It discusses theoretical principles in a wide variety of areas such as management of change, risk analysis and incident investigation, and then goes on to show how these principles work in practice, either in the design office or in an operating facility. The second edition has been expanded, revised and updated and many new sections have been added including: The impact of resource limitations, a review of some recent major incidents, the value of story-telling as a means of conveying process safety values and principles, and the impact of the proposed changes to the OSHA PSM standard.
- Learn how to develop a thorough and complete process safety management program.
- Go beyond traditional hazards analysis and risk management programs to explore a company's entire range of procedures, processes and management issues.
- Understand how to develop a culture of process safety and operational excellence that goes beyond simple rule compliance.
- Develop process safety programs for both onshore facilities (EPA, OSHA) and offshore platforms and rigs (BSEE) and to meet Safety Case requirements.
Inhaltsverzeichnis
1;Front Cover;1 2;Process Risk and Reliability Management;4 3;Copyright Page;5 4;Contents;6 5;Preface;14 6;1 Risk Management;16 6.1;Introduction;16 6.2;Technical, Process, and Occupational Safety;18 6.3;Historical Development;19 6.3.1;1. Safety as a Value;20 6.3.2;2. Codes and Standards;20 6.3.3;3. Workers Compensation;20 6.3.4;4. Occupational Safety;20 6.3.5;5. Systems Analysis;21 6.3.6;6. Regulations;21 6.3.7;7. Management Systems;21 6.3.8;8. Behavior-Based Safety;23 6.3.9;9. Safety Culture;24 6.4;Major Events;24 6.5;Health, Safety, and Environmental Programs;25 6.5.1;Environmental/Sustainability;25 6.5.2;Health;26 6.5.3;Safety;26 6.6;Prescriptive/Nonprescriptive;26 6.6.1;Safety Management Programs;28 6.6.2;Regulations;28 6.6.3;The Regulators Dilemma;29 6.7;Process Safety Management;29 6.7.1;Definition of PSM;31 6.7.2;Safe Limits;31 6.7.3;Set Point Values;33 6.7.4;Operating, Safe, and Emergency Limits;34 6.7.5;Measurement Strategies;36 6.7.6;Involvement;40 6.7.7;Thoroughness;40 6.7.8;Holistic;40 6.8;Environment;41 6.9;Quality Management;41 6.9.1;Statistical Process Control;41 6.9.2;ISO 9000/14001;42 6.9.3;Six Sigma;42 6.10;Risk;42 6.11;Components of Risk;43 6.11.1;Hazards;44 6.11.2;Consequence;44 6.11.3;Predicted Frequency;45 6.11.4;Safeguards;45 6.11.5;Presence of Persons;46 6.11.6;Single Contingency Events;47 6.11.7;Economies of Scale;47 6.12;Common Cause Events;48 6.12.1;FukushimaDaiichi;48 6.12.2;Examples;48 6.12.2.1;Utility Failure;48 6.12.2.2;Instruments on Manual;48 6.12.2.3;Instrument Pluggage;49 6.12.2.4;Vibration;49 6.12.2.5;External Events;49 6.12.2.6;Maintenance Availability;49 6.12.2.7;Human Error/Untrained Personnel;49 6.13;Subjective Nature of Risk;49 6.13.1;Degree of Control;50 6.13.2;Familiarity with the Hazard;50 6.13.3;Direct Benefit;51 6.13.4;Personal Impact;51 6.13.5;Natural vs. Man-Made Risks;51 6.13.6;Recency of Events;51 6.13.7;Perception of the Consequence Term;51 6.13.8;Comprehension Time;53 6.13.9;Randomness;53 6.13.10;Regression to the
Mean;53 6.13.11;Bias Toward Positive Evidence/Prior Beliefs;53 6.13.12;Availability;54 6.14;Quantification of Risk;54 6.14.1;Mathematical Terms;54 6.14.1.1;Frequency;54 6.14.1.2;Predicted Frequency;55 6.14.1.3;Probability;55 6.14.1.4;Likelihood and Failure Rate;55 6.14.1.5;Error/Statistical Significance Confidence;55 6.14.1.6;Failure/Fault;56 6.14.1.7;Independence and Randomness;56 6.14.2;FN Curves;56 6.14.3;Limitations;56 6.15;Acceptable Risk;58 6.15.1;The Third Law;59 6.15.2;Perfection as a Slogan;59 6.15.3;As Low as Reasonably Practical;60 6.15.4;De minimis Risk;61 6.15.5;Citations/Case Law;61 6.15.6;RAGAGEP;62 6.15.7;Indexing Methods;62 6.16;Risk Matrices;62 6.16.1;Consequence Matrix;62 6.16.1.1;Worker Safety;63 6.16.1.2;Public Safety and Health;63 6.16.1.3;Environmental Impact;63 6.16.1.4;Economic Loss;64 6.16.2;Frequency Matrix;64 6.16.3;Risk Matrix;65 6.16.3.1;A(Red) Very High;66 6.16.3.2;B(Orange) High;66 6.16.3.3;C(Yellow) Moderate;66 6.16.3.4;D(Green) Low;66 6.16.3.5;Other Categories;66 6.16.4;Limitations of Risk Matrices;67 6.16.4.1;Low-Hanging Fruit;68 6.16.4.2;Prepare for the Worst Case;68 6.16.4.3;Expensive Good Ideas;68 6.17;Black Swan Events;68 6.18;Different Industries;69 6.18.1;Oil Refineries;69 6.18.2;Offshore Oil and Gas;70 6.18.2.1;Lack of Escape Routes;71 6.18.2.2;Persons on Board;71 6.18.2.3;Cyclones/Hurricanes;72 6.18.2.4;Downers and Leaners;72 6.18.2.5;Blowouts;73 6.18.2.6;Hydrogen Sulfide;73 6.18.2.7;Dropped Objects;73 6.18.2.8;Helicopters;74 6.18.2.9;Ship Collision/Mooring Failure;74 6.18.2.10;Spill Response;74 6.18.3;Pipelines;74 6.19;Examples;75 6.19.1;Example 1Facility Design;75 6.19.2;Example 2Process Flow;76 6.19.3;Example 3Heat Exchanger;77 6.19.4;Example 4Risk Management Workflow;77 6.19.4.1;External Standard;78 6.19.4.2;Guidance;78 6.19.4.3;Risk Analysis Plan and Implement;78 6.19.4.4;Audit/Deltas;78 6.19.4.5;Success/Continuous Improvement;78 6.19.5;Example 5: Significant Potential Incident;79 7;2 Compliance and Standards;80 7.1;In
troduction;81 7.2;Regulations;81 7.2.1;Rule-Based Approach;82 7.2.2;Goal-Driven Approach;83 7.2.3;Process Safety Regulations;84 7.3;Codes and Standards;85 7.3.1;Development of a Standard;86 7.3.2;Standards Organizations;87 7.3.2.1;American Chemistry Council/Responsible Care;87 7.3.2.2;American National Standards Institute;89 7.3.2.3;American Petroleum Institute;89 7.3.2.4;American Society of Mechanical Engineers;90 7.3.2.5;International Organization for Standardization;90 7.3.2.6;National Fire Protection Association;92 7.3.3;Other Industry Sources;92 7.3.3.1;Center for Chemical Process Safety;92 7.3.3.2;Center for Offshore Safety;93 7.3.3.3;Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board;93 7.4;Company Standards;93 7.5;Industry Information;94 7.5.1;Regulatory Guidance;94 7.5.2;Open Literature;94 7.6;Commercial Information;95 7.7;Analysis;95 7.8;United States Federal Regulations;95 7.8.1;The Regulatory Process;95 7.8.2;Code of Federal Regulations;96 7.8.3;General Duty Clauses;97 7.8.4;The Tenth Amendment to the United States Constitution;97 7.8.5;The EPA;98 7.9;The Occupational Safety & Health Administration;98 7.9.1;OSHA Inspections;99 7.9.1.1;Variances;100 7.9.1.2;Enforcement;100 7.9.2;The Entry Process;101 7.9.2.1;Fatality/Catastrophe;101 7.9.2.2;Programmed Inspections;101 7.9.2.3;Complaints;102 7.9.3;Citations;102 7.9.3.1;Willful;102 7.9.3.2;Serious;103 7.9.3.3;Other-than-Serious;103 7.9.3.4;Repeat and Failure-to-Abate;104 7.9.4;OSHA Standards;104 7.9.4.1;Part 29;104 7.9.4.2;Subparts of Part 29;104 7.9.4.3;Sections of Subparts;106 7.9.5;Interpretations and Guidance;106 7.10;The OSHA PSM Standard;108 7.10.1;Covered Processes;108 7.10.2;Other Standards;109 7.10.3;Audit Guidelines;109 7.10.4;National Emphasis Programs;109 7.10.5;Proposed Update;111 7.10.5.1;1. Atmospheric Storage Tanks;112 7.10.5.2;2. Oil and Gas Well Drilling and Servicing;112 7.10.5.3;3. Oil and Gas Production Facilities;112 7.10.5.4;4. Reactivity Hazards;113 7.10.5.5;5. Highly Hazardous Chemicals;
113 7.10.5.6;6. Management System Elements;113 7.10.5.7;7. RAGAGEP;113 7.10.5.8;8. Definition of RAGAGEP;113 7.10.5.9;9. Safety Critical Equipment;114 7.10.5.10;10. Organizational Changes;114 7.10.5.11;11. Emergency Planning;114 7.10.5.12;12. Third-Party Compliance Audits;114 7.10.5.13;13. Explosives, Blasting Agents, and Pyrotechnics;114 7.10.5.14;14. Flammable Liquids and Spray Finishing;114 7.10.5.15;15. Ammonium Nitrate;114 7.10.5.16;16. Retail Facilities;115 7.10.5.17;17. Concentrations of Highly Hazardous Chemicals;115 7.11;The EPA;115 7.12;The EPA Risk Management Program40 CFR 68;115 7.12.1;Tiering/Program Levels;116 7.12.2;Covered Chemicals;116 7.12.3;Formal Management System;116 7.12.4;Worst Case Release;116 7.12.5;Emergency Plan;117 7.12.6;Five-Year Accident History;117 7.13;BSEE;117 7.14;State Regulations;118 7.14.1;New Jersey Toxic Catastrophe Prevention Act;118 7.14.2;Delaware/Nevada;119 7.15;The Safety Case Regime;119 7.15.1;Elements of a Safety Case;120 7.15.1.1;Duty-Holder Responsibility;120 7.15.1.2;Responsibility of the Auditor/Assessor;120 7.15.1.3;Risk Management System;120 7.15.1.4;Management Systems;120 7.15.1.5;Living Document;121 7.15.2;Structure of a Safety Case;121 7.15.2.1;1. Facility Description;121 7.15.2.2;2. Safety Management System;121 7.15.2.3;3. Formal Safety Assessment;122 7.15.3;Preparation and Implementation;123 7.15.4;Assessment;123 7.15.5;Performance Measurement;124 7.16;International Agencies;125 7.17;Elements of PSM;125 7.17.1;1. Employee Participation;125 7.17.1.1;Written Plan of Action;126 7.17.1.2;Consultation;126 7.17.1.3;Access to Information;126 7.17.2;2. Process Safety Information;127 7.17.3;3. Process Hazards Analysis;129 7.17.3.1;Initial Hazard Analysis;131 7.17.3.2;Methodology;131 7.17.3.3;Issues to Address;131 7.17.3.4;Team;132 7.17.3.5;Revalidation;132 7.17.4;4. Operating Procedures;132 7.17.4.1;Written Down;134 7.17.4.2;Initial Startup;134 7.17.4.3;Temporary and Emergency Operations;134 7.17.4.4;Certification;134
7.17.5;5. Training;135 7.17.6;6. Contractors;137 7.17.6.1;Application;138 7.17.6.2;Employer Responsibilities;138 7.17.7;7. Prestartup Safety Review;139 7.17.7.1;Process Safety Information;139 7.17.7.2;Construction and Equipment;140 7.17.7.3;Procedures;140 7.17.7.4;New/Modified Facilities;140 7.17.8;8. Mechanical Integrity;140 7.17.8.1;Application;142 7.17.8.2;Written Procedures;142 7.17.8.3;Training;142 7.17.8.4;Inspection and Testing;143 7.17.8.5;Deficiencies;143 7.17.8.6;Quality Assurance;143 7.17.9;9. Hot Work;143 7.17.10;10. Management of Change;144 7.17.10.1;Employer Responsibility;145 7.17.10.2;Written Down;145 7.17.10.3;Replacement In-Kind;146 7.17.10.4;Factors that Affect Change;146 7.17.10.5;Training and Participation/Accountability;146 7.17.10.6;Information Base;146 7.17.10.7;Operating Procedures;146 7.17.10.8;Making the Change;147 7.17.10.9;Training/PSI/Operating Procedures;147 7.17.11;11. Incident Investigation;147 7.17.11.1;Investigation;148 7.17.11.2;Timing;148 7.17.11.3;Team;148 7.17.11.4;Report;148 7.17.11.5;Follow up;148 7.17.11.6;Participation;148 7.17.12;12. Emergency Planning and Response;148 7.17.13;13. Compliance Audits;151 7.17.13.1;Certification;153 7.17.13.2;Technical Qualifications;153 7.17.13.3;Report;153 7.17.13.4;Response;153 7.17.13.5;Retention of Reports;153 8;3 Culture and Participation;154 8.1;Introduction;154 8.2;Regulations and Standards;155 8.2.1;BSEE Standard for Culture;155 8.2.2;HSE and Culture;157 8.2.3;National Energy Board;157 8.2.4;Survey;158 8.3;Warning Flags over Your Organization;158 8.3.1;Flag OneUnrealistic Stretch Goals;159 8.3.1.1;Production Creep;159 8.3.1.2;Production Records;159 8.3.1.3;Initiative Overload;160 8.3.2;Flag TwoExcessive Cost Reduction;160 8.3.2.1;Reduction of Nonessentials;162 8.3.2.2;Reductions in Workforce;162 8.3.2.3;The Big Crew Change;163 8.3.2.4;Flattened Organizations;163 8.3.2.5;Aging Infrastructure;164 8.3.2.6;Outsourcing;164 8.3.2.7;Not Enough Time for Detailed Work;164 8.3.2.8;Project Cut
backs;164 8.3.2.9;Organizational Spread;165 8.3.3;Flag ThreeBelief That It Cannot Happen Here;165 8.3.3.1;Lack of Direct Experience;165 8.3.3.2;Good Occupational Safety Performance;165 8.3.3.3;Failure to Learn from Near Misses;166 8.3.3.4;Failure to Draw on Experience Elsewhere;166 8.3.4;Flag FourOverconfidence in Rule Compliance;166 8.3.5;Flag FiveDepartmentalized Information Flow;166 8.3.5.1;Critical Safety Information Is Buried, Lost, or Diluted;167 8.3.5.2;Team Player Culture;167 8.3.5.3;Fear of Litigation;168 8.3.5.4;Mergers, Acquisitions, and Divestitures;168 8.3.6;Flag SixIneffective Audit Process;168 8.3.6.1;Softened News to Senior Managers;168 8.3.6.2;Failure to Identify Root Causes;169 8.3.6.3;Inadequate Follow-Up;169 8.4;Thinking Backward;169 8.5;Imagination;170 8.6;Culture Matrices;170 8.6.1;Elements of Culture;171 8.6.1.1;Ongoing and Consistent;171 8.6.1.2;Actions and Words;172 8.6.1.3;External Evaluation;172 8.6.1.4;Learning from Incidents;172 8.6.1.5;Attention to Basics/Housekeeping;173 8.6.2;Mergers and Acquisitions;173 8.6.3;Generational Differences;174 8.7;Measurement;174 8.8;Key Performance Indicators;175 8.9;Lagging and Leading Indicators;175 8.9.1;Lagging Indicators;176 8.9.1.1;OSHA Recordable Rate;177 8.9.1.2;Process Safety;177 8.9.2;Leading Indicators;178 8.9.2.1;Near Misses;179 8.9.2.2;Unplanned Maintenance;179 8.9.2.3;Process Safety Incident;179 8.9.3;KPI Limitations;180 8.9.3.1;Activity and Quality;180 8.9.3.2;Quality of Reporting;180 8.9.3.3;Management Elements;181 8.10;API RP 754;181 8.10.1;Tiers;182 8.10.1.1;Tier 1Process Safety Event;183 8.10.1.2;Tier 2Process Safety Event;184 8.10.1.3;Tier 3Challenge to Safety Systems;184 8.10.1.4;Tier 4Operating Discipline and Management System Performance;184 8.10.2;Data Submission;184 8.11;Selection of KPIs;184 8.12;Surveys;185 8.13;Creating a Strong Culture;186 8.13.1;Mission Statement;186 8.13.2;Guiding Tenets;187 8.13.3;Detailed Program;187 8.14;Behavior-Based Safety;188 8.14.1;Observed Hazard Ca
rd;189 8.14.2;Five by Five Policy;189 8.14.3;Off-the-Job Safety;190 8.14.4;Pointless Activities;190 8.15;Employee Participation;190 8.15.1;Developing Employee Participation;191 8.15.1.1;Safety Committees;191 8.15.1.2;Involvement in PSM elements;191 8.15.2;Difficulties with Workforce Involvement;192 8.15.2.1;Inefficiencies;192 8.15.2.2;Unwillingness to Accept Change;192 8.15.2.3;Labor/Management Relations;192 8.16;Stakeholder Outreach;192 9;4 Technical Information;194 9.1;Introduction;194 9.2;Table of Contents;195 9.3;Process Description;197 9.4;Flowsheets;197 9.4.1;Block Flow Diagrams;197 9.4.2;Process Flow Diagrams;198 9.4.3;Piping & Instrument Diagrams;199 9.4.3.1;Design Phases;200 9.4.3.2;Equipment and Line Designations;200 9.4.3.3;Instrument Designations;201 9.4.3.4;Updating P&IDs;201 9.4.4;Editing Engineering Information;201 9.5;Materials of Construction Table;202 9.6;MSDS or Safety Data Sheet;202 9.7;Global Harmonization System;205 9.8;The Safety Diamond;205 10;5 Hazard Identification;208 10.1;Introduction;208 10.2;Hazards Management Process;210 10.2.1;Step 1. Identify the Hazards;211 10.2.1.1;Creative/Imaginative Techniques;212 10.2.1.2;Experience Based;213 10.2.1.3;Logical/Rational;214 10.2.2;Step 2. Risk Rank;214 10.2.3;Step 3. Eliminate or Substitute the Hazard;214 10.2.4;Step 4. Remove the People;214 10.2.5;Step 5. Reduce the Consequence;215 10.2.6;Step 6. Reduce the Likelihood;215 10.2.7;Step 7. Install Safeguards;215 10.3;Organization of a Hazards Analysis;215 10.3.1;Charge/Scope Letter;217 10.3.1.1;Objective;217 10.3.1.2;Physical Scope;217 10.3.1.3;Method(s) To Be Used;217 10.3.1.4;Assigned Personnel;217 10.3.1.5;Risk Management Guidance;217 10.3.1.6;Schedule and Reporting;218 10.3.2;Abandoned Equipment;218 10.3.3;Preparations;218 10.3.4;Logistics;218 10.3.5;Meeting Protocol;219 10.3.6;Location of the Meeting;219 10.3.7;Projection of Notes;219 10.3.8;Documentation Requirements;220 10.3.9;Security of the Information;220 10.3.10;Time Required;220 10.3.11
;Kick-Off and Close-Out Meetings;221 10.4;The Team;222 10.4.1;Leader/Facilitator;223 10.4.1.1;Process Knowledge;223 10.4.1.2;Stimulate Thinking;224 10.4.1.3;Creative Thinking;224 10.4.1.4;Casual Remarks;224 10.4.1.5;If We had Unlimited Money;225 10.4.1.6;Generalizations;225 10.4.1.7;Team Management;225 10.4.1.8;Knowledge of Actual Incidents;226 10.4.1.9;Lawyer-like Behavior;227 10.4.1.10;Persona;227 10.4.1.11;Personal Preparation;227 10.4.1.12;Engineering Standards;227 10.4.2;The Scribe;228 10.4.3;Operations/Maintenance Expert;228 10.4.4;Process and Instrument Experts;228 10.4.5;Specialists;228 10.4.6;Use of Sophisticated Language;229 10.4.7;The One-Minute Engineering Department;229 10.5;Results of the Analysis;230 10.5.1;Findings;230 10.5.2;Recommendations;230 10.5.3;Action Items;231 10.5.4;Risk Register;232 10.5.4.1;Finding Number and Date;232 10.5.4.2;Hazard;232 10.5.4.3;Source;233 10.5.4.4;Consequence(s)/Likelihood/Risk;233 10.5.4.5;Follow-up;233 10.6;The Hazards Analysis Report;233 10.6.1;Completeness of the Notes;234 10.6.2;Cross-Reference;235 10.6.3;Anonymity;235 10.6.3.1;Findings Terminology;235 10.6.3.2;Completeness;236 10.6.3.3;Nonfindings;236 10.6.3.4;Appearance;236 10.6.3.5;Pictures;236 10.6.4;Report Distribution;236 10.6.5;Communication with the Public;237 10.6.6;Table of Contents;237 10.6.6.1;1. Disclaimer;237 10.6.6.2;2. Executive Summary;238 10.6.6.3;3. Objectives of the Analysis;238 10.6.6.4;4. Summary of Findings;238 10.6.6.5;5. Method Used;239 10.6.6.6;6. Risk Ranking;239 10.6.6.7;7. The Team;239 10.6.6.8;8. Regulations and Standards;240 10.6.6.9;9. Attachments;240 10.6.6.10;10. Meeting Notes;240 10.6.7;Development of the Report;240 10.6.7.1;Step 1. Notes Cleanup;241 10.6.7.2;Step 2. Team Review;241 10.6.7.3;Step 3. Draft Report;242 10.6.7.4;Step 4. Client Review;243 10.6.7.5;Step 5. Final Report;244 10.6.7.6;Step 6. Risk Register;244 10.6.8;Legal Issues;244 10.6.8.1;Need to Act on Findings;246 10.6.8.2;Informal Notes;246 10.6.8.3;Internal Communi
cation;246 10.6.8.4;PHA Leadership;247 10.7;Special Types of Hazards Analysis;247 10.7.1;Temporary and Transient Operations;248 10.7.2;Nonprocess Applications;248 10.7.3;Decommissioning/Demolition;248 10.8;Revalidation Hazards Analyses;249 10.9;Benefits and Limitations of Hazard Analyses;250 10.9.1;Strengths;250 10.9.1.1;Providing Time to Think;251 10.9.1.2;Challenging Conventional Thinking;251 10.9.1.3;Cross-discipline Communication;251 10.9.1.4;Education;251 10.9.1.5;Development of Technical Information;251 10.9.1.6;Economic Payoff;251 10.9.2;Limitations and Concerns;252 10.9.2.1;Imprecision in Defining Terms;253 10.9.2.2;Multiple Contingencies;253 10.9.2.3;Complexities and Subtle Interactions;253 10.9.2.4;Dynamic Conditions;254 10.9.2.5;Knowledge of Safe Operating Limits;254 10.9.2.6;Lack of Quantification;254 10.9.2.7;Team Quality;254 10.9.2.8;Personal Experience;255 10.9.2.9;Boredom;255 10.9.2.10;TRIZ;255 10.9.2.11;Confusion with Design Reviews;256 10.9.2.12;False Confidence;256 10.9.2.13;Equipment Orientation;257 10.9.2.14;Interfaces;257 10.9.2.15;Human Error;257 10.10;HAZID/MHS;258 10.11;The HAZOP Method;259 10.11.1;Step 1. Node Selection and Purpose;260 10.11.1.1;Selection of Nodes;261 10.11.1.2;Pressure/Spec Breaks;262 10.11.2;Step 2. Process Guideword/Safe Limits;262 10.11.3;Step 3. Identification of Hazards and their Causes;263 10.11.4;Step 4. Announcement of the Hazard;265 10.11.5;Step 5. Consequences;265 10.11.6;Step 6. Identification of Safeguards;266 10.11.7;Step 7. Predicted Frequency of Occurrence of the Hazard;267 10.11.8;Step 8. Risk Rank;268 10.11.9;Step 9. Findings;268 10.11.10;Step 10. Next Process Guideword/Node;268 10.11.11;Effectiveness of HAZOPs;268 10.12;Checklists;269 10.12.1;Checklist Categories and Guidewords;269 10.12.2;Structure of a Checklist;269 10.13;The What-If Method;270 10.13.1;Node/Functional Area Review;274 10.13.2;Equipment and Function Review;275 10.13.3;Ignition Source Controls;275 10.13.4;Instrumentation and Control System
s;275 10.13.5;Human Factors;276 10.13.6;Process Upsets;276 10.13.7;Siting;276 10.13.8;Structured What-If;276 10.13.9;Utility Systems;277 10.13.10;Batch Processes;277 10.13.11;Operating Procedures;278 10.13.12;Layout Reviews;278 10.14;What-If/Checklist Method;278 10.15;Failure Modes And Effects Analysis;279 10.16;Bow Tie Analysis;280 10.17;Indexing Methods;282 10.18;Interface Hazards Analysis;284 11;6 Operating Procedures;287 11.1;Introduction;288 11.2;Definition of Operating Procedures;292 11.2.1;Operations;292 11.2.2;Written Instructions;293 11.2.3;Design or Operating Intent;293 11.3;Definition of Maintenance Procedures;294 11.4;Terminology;294 11.5;Engineering the Solution;294 11.6;Quick Assessment of Operating Procedures;298 11.7;The Users;300 11.7.1;Experienced Technicians;300 11.7.2;Less Experienced Technicians;300 11.7.3;Engineering/Management;300 11.7.4;DCS/SCADA Programmers;300 11.7.5;Auditors, Regulators, and Inspectors;300 11.7.6;Translators;300 11.8;Elements of Operational Integrity Management;301 11.8.1;Workforce Involvement;301 11.8.2;Knowledge Management;301 11.8.3;Hazard Identification and Risk Management;303 11.8.4;Management of Change;303 11.8.5;Operational Readiness;303 11.8.6;Emergency Management;303 11.8.7;Technical Information;304 11.9;Types of Operating Procedure;304 11.10;Steady-State Operating Procedures;304 11.10.1;Types of Steady-State Procedure;304 11.10.2;Shift Change;305 11.11;Start-Up Procedures;305 11.12;Shutdown Procedures;307 11.12.1;Levels of Shutdown;308 11.12.1.1;Standby;308 11.12.1.2;Unit Shutdown;308 11.12.1.3;Facility Shutdown;308 11.12.1.4;Emergency Shutdown;308 11.12.1.5;Turnaround;309 11.13;Troubleshooting Procedures;309 11.13.1;Elements of Troubleshooting Procedures;310 11.13.2;Structure of Troubleshooting Procedures;311 11.14;Temporary Operating Procedures;311 11.15;Batch Procedures;312 11.16;Standard Operating Procedures;313 11.17;Maintenance Procedures;317 11.18;Job Safe Practices;317 11.19;Software Analogy;317 11.19.1;M
odular Design;319 11.19.1.1;Connecting the Modules;320 11.19.1.2;If/Then/Else Instructions;321 11.19.1.3;Modular operating manual;321 11.19.2;Database Structure;322 11.19.3;Top-Down Development;323 11.19.4;Prototyping;326 11.19.5;Limitations of Modularity;328 11.20;Design of an Operating Manual;328 11.20.1;Adding and Removing Modules;331 11.20.2;Numbering the Modules;332 11.21;Module Design;332 11.21.1;The Title Block;333 11.21.1.1;Procedure name;334 11.21.1.2;Module number;335 11.21.1.3;Purpose of the procedure;335 11.21.1.4;Revision number;335 11.21.1.5;Date of revision;335 11.21.1.6;Covered persons;335 11.21.1.7;Company/Facility;336 11.21.1.8;Safe upper and lower limits;336 11.21.1.9;Special safety items;336 11.21.1.10;Equipment information;336 11.21.1.11;Training;336 11.21.2;The Operating Task Instructions;336 11.21.2.1;Step number column;337 11.21.2.2;Person;337 11.21.2.3;Action;338 11.21.2.4;Discussion/Illustration;338 11.21.3;The Authorization Block;338 11.21.3.1;Written by;339 11.21.3.2;Approvalsuperintendent;339 11.21.3.3;Approvalmanager;339 11.21.3.4;Authorization sheet;340 11.21.4;Overall Module;340 11.21.5;Links to Other Procedures and Manuals;340 11.21.6;Links to Technical Information;340 11.21.7;Training;342 11.21.8;Two-Page Modules;342 11.22;Content Development;344 11.22.1;Level of Detail;344 11.22.1.1;Level 1overview/checklists;344 11.22.1.2;Level 2equipment description;345 11.22.1.3;Level 3valve detail;345 11.22.2;Sources of Information;346 11.22.2.1;Existing procedures;346 11.22.2.2;Technician interviews;346 11.22.2.3;Engineering information;346 11.22.2.4;Vendor manuals;346 11.22.2.5;Process hazards analyses;347 11.23;The Procedures-Writing Team;347 11.24;Writing and Publishing;347 11.25;Project Organization;348 11.26;1. Define the Scope of Work;348 11.26.1;Physical Area/Equipment Covered;349 11.26.2;Users;349 11.26.3;Types of Procedure;349 11.26.4;Job Task Analysis;349 11.26.5;Design of the Manual;350 11.26.6;Regulations/Standards;350 11.26.7;Writ
ers Guide;350 11.27;2. Create the Team;350 11.27.1;Steering Committee;350 11.27.2;Project Manager;351 11.27.3;Project Lead;351 11.27.4;Technicians;351 11.27.5;Technology Expert;352 11.27.6;Interviewer-Writers;352 11.27.7;Publisher/Webmaster;352 11.28;3. Develop a Detailed Plan;352 11.28.1;Schedule and Progress Metric;353 11.28.2;Budget;354 11.28.3;Prepare the SOPs;355 11.29;4. Collect Information;355 11.29.1;Operator Interviews;355 11.29.2;Existing Procedures/Vendor Manuals;355 11.29.3;Logbooks;356 11.30;5. Write the Procedures;356 11.30.1;Draft Releases;356 11.30.2;Plan to Throw One AwayYou Will Anyway;357 11.31;6. Review and Sign;357 11.32;7. Publish;357 11.33;Potential Difficulties;358 11.33.1;Poorly Defined Goals;358 11.33.2;Too Many People;358 11.33.3;Extended Review Cycle;358 11.33.4;Lack of Signatures;359 11.34;Maintaining the Procedures;359 11.34.1;Procedures Modification Process;361 11.34.2;Organization;361 11.35;Writing Guidelines;362 11.36;Vigorous Writing;363 11.36.1;Minimalist Writing;363 11.36.2;Short, Pithy Instructions;364 11.36.3;Avoid Repetition of Instructions;364 11.36.4;Omit Needless Words;364 11.36.5;Omit Adverbs;364 11.36.6;Short and Old Words;365 11.36.7;Avoid Wordy Phrases and Padded Syllables;366 11.37;Writing Style;366 11.37.1;Imperative Tense;367 11.37.2;Active Voice;367 11.37.3;Reading Grade Level;368 11.37.4;List Instructions Singly;369 11.37.5;Implied Instructions;369 11.37.6;Bulleted Lists;369 11.37.7;Conditional Instructions;369 11.37.8;Positive/Negative Instructions;370 11.38;Vocabulary;370 11.38.1;Identification of Equipment;371 11.38.2;Consistency;371 11.38.3;Should/Would/Could;371 11.38.4;The Word You;372 11.38.5;The Word This;372 11.38.6;Arabic Numerals;372 11.38.7;Adverbs and Adjectives;372 11.38.8;Articles;373 11.38.9;Humor;373 11.38.10;Spelling;373 11.38.11;Latinate Abbreviations;374 11.38.12;Apostrophes;375 11.38.13;Ambiguous Words;375 11.39;Repetition of Messages;376 11.39.1;Danger, Warning, Caution, Note;376 11.39.2;Proofr
eader Marks;377 11.40;Illustrations;377 11.40.1;Photographs;378 11.40.2;P&IDs;378 11.40.3;Iconic Flow Diagrams/Schematics;378 11.40.4;Maps/Plot Plans;379 11.41;Publishing;380 11.41.1;Color;380 11.41.2;White Space;381 11.41.3;Fonts;381 11.41.4;Paragraph Formatting;381 11.41.5;Emphasis Techniques;382 11.41.6;Heading;382 11.41.7;Page Numbering;383 11.41.8;Single-Sided Versus Double-Sided Printing;383 11.41.9;Indexing;383 11.41.10;Glossary;383 11.41.11;The Binder;383 11.42;Multiple Languages;384 12;7 Training and Competence;385 12.1;Introduction;385 12.2;Levels of Competence;386 12.2.1;Level 1Basic Skills;386 12.2.2;Level 2Certification;386 12.2.3;Level 3Master Technician;387 12.3;Elements of a Training Program;387 12.3.1;Orientation;387 12.3.2;Initial/Basic Training;388 12.3.3;Site Training;389 12.3.4;Abnormal Situation Management;389 12.3.5;Refresher Training;389 12.4;SEMS (BSEE);390 12.5;PSM (OSHA);390 12.6;Procedures and Training;394 12.7;Management of a Training Program;395 12.7.1;Training Matrix;396 12.7.2;Budget Allocation;396 12.7.3;Measuring Progress;397 12.8;Economics of Training;398 12.9;Process Simulators and Emulators;399 12.9.1;Features;399 12.9.2;Benefits;399 12.9.3;Simulator Design;400 12.10;Testing and Certification;402 12.11;SafeGulf;403 12.12;Pipeline Operator Training;404 13;8 Prestartup Reviews;405 13.1;Introduction;405 13.2;What the Review Is Not;406 13.3;Regulations;407 13.3.1;OSHAs PSM;407 13.3.1.1;(i) Construction and equipment;407 13.3.1.2;(ii) Procedures;408 13.3.1.3;(iii) New/modified facilities;408 13.3.2;SEMS;408 13.4;Types of Review;409 13.4.1;Review Not Required;409 13.4.2;Small Projects/Engineering Changes;409 13.4.3;Medium Size;409 13.4.4;Large Projects;409 13.5;Restart Reviews;410 13.6;Organizational Responsibility;410 13.6.1;Time Required;411 13.6.2;Team Structure;411 13.7;Using the Elements of PSM;411 13.7.1;Knowledge Management;411 13.7.2;Operating Procedures;412 13.7.3;Asset Integrity/Reliability;412 13.7.4;Training/Performance;412
14;9 Asset Integrity;413 14.1;Introduction;413 14.2;Engineering Standards;413 14.3;Inherent Safety;414 14.3.1;Eliminate;414 14.3.1.1;Remove equipment;415 14.3.1.2;Remove people;415 14.3.2;Minimize;416 14.3.3;Substitute;416 14.3.4;Moderate;416 14.3.4.1;Equipment modification;417 14.3.4.2;Spacing;417 14.3.4.3;Underground location;417 14.3.5;Simplify;417 14.3.6;Applying Inherent Safety;418 14.3.7;Law of Unintended Consequences;419 14.3.7.1;Serendipity;419 14.3.7.2;Undesirable outcome;420 14.3.7.3;Original situation worse;420 14.3.8;Passive Safety Systems;420 14.3.9;Active Safety Systems;420 14.3.10;Administrative Safety Systems;421 14.3.11;Safety Critical Items;421 14.3.11.1;Priority 1;421 14.3.11.2;Priority 2;422 14.3.11.3;Priority 3;422 14.4;RAGAGEP;422 15;10 Management of Change;423 15.1;Introduction;423 15.2;Benefits of MOC;424 15.2.1;Increased Production, Productivity, and Quality;424 15.2.2;Maintenance Expense and Safety;424 15.2.3;Environmental Performance;424 15.2.4;Personal Reputation;425 15.3;Definition of MOC;425 15.3.1;Deviation Beyond Limits;426 15.3.2;Impact on Other Process Safety Elements;426 15.3.3;Critical Changes;426 15.4;In-Kind/Not-In-Kind Change;427 15.4.1;Same Specification;427 15.4.2;Same Service and Materials of Construction;428 15.4.3;Same Storage and Handling Process;428 15.4.4;Procedural Replacement;428 15.4.5;Process Chemistry;428 15.4.6;Instrumentation and Control Systems;429 15.5;Types of Change;429 15.5.1;Initiated Equipment Change;429 15.5.1.1;Large and small changes;430 15.5.1.2;Turnarounds;430 15.5.1.3;Field change;430 15.5.2;Noninitiated Equipment Change;430 15.5.2.1;Overt change;431 15.5.2.2;Covert change;431 15.5.3;Temporary Changes;432 15.5.4;Emergency Changes;433 15.5.5;Administrative and Organizational Change;434 15.5.5.1;Reorganization;435 15.5.5.2;Management by contractors;435 15.6;Informal Aspects of MOC;435 15.7;The MOC Process;437 15.8;Section AInitiator Request;437 15.8.1;Initiator;438 15.8.1.1;Personal recognition;438 15
.8.1.2;Company loyalty;438 15.8.1.3;Safety;438 15.8.2;Sponsor;439 15.8.3;Request Process;439 15.8.3.1;Step 1problem/opportunity identified;440 15.8.3.2;Step 2need for change;440 15.8.3.3;Step 3corrective action;440 15.8.3.4;Step 4system change;441 15.8.4;MOC FormSection A;441 15.8.4.1;Name of the Sponsor/Initiator(s)/date;441 15.8.4.2;Description of problem and its consequences;441 15.8.4.3;Proposed change;441 15.8.4.4;Justification;443 15.8.4.5;Emergency change/temporary change;443 15.8.4.6;Previous actions taken;443 15.9;Section BFirst Review;444 15.9.1;In-Kind/Not-In-Kind Change;445 15.9.2;Selecting the First Reviewers;445 15.9.3;MOC FormSection B;446 15.9.3.1;Name/date;446 15.9.3.2;Discussion;446 15.9.3.3;Suggested modifications;446 15.10;Section CDetailed Evaluation;447 15.10.1;Review Process;447 15.10.1.1;Information only;447 15.10.1.2;Approval;447 15.10.1.3;Modify the document;447 15.10.2;MOC Coordinator;449 15.10.3;Review Team;449 15.10.3.1;Process manager;449 15.10.3.2;Engineering manager;449 15.10.3.3;Operations manager;450 15.10.4;Builders;450 15.10.5;Project Team;450 15.10.6;Software;451 15.10.7;Reviewers;451 15.10.7.1;1. Confirm the problem;451 15.10.7.2;2. Problem analysis;451 15.10.7.3;3. Identify possible solutions;451 15.10.8;Qualifications;451 15.10.8.1;Experience;452 15.10.8.2;Technical knowledge;452 15.10.8.3;Feasibility;452 15.10.8.4;Out-of-the-Box thinking;452 15.10.9;Recommendations;453 15.10.10;MOC FormSection C;453 15.11;Section DFormal Approval;453 15.11.1;MOC Committee;453 15.11.1.1;Operations;455 15.11.1.2;Maintenance;455 15.11.1.3;Technical;455 15.11.1.4;Engineering/construction;455 15.11.2;Process Hazards Analysis;455 15.11.3;Variance Procedures;456 15.12;Section ENew Limits/Process Safety Update;456 15.13;Section FNotification;457 15.14;Section GImplementation;458 15.15;Section HFollow-Up;458 16;11 Incident Investigation and Root Cause Analysis;460 16.1;Introduction;460 16.2;Management Level;461 16.2.1;Line Supervision;462 16.2.2;Facil
ity Management;462 16.2.3;Executive Management;462 16.2.4;Industry Regulations and Standards;463 16.3;Incident Investigation and Analysis Philosophy;463 16.3.1;Trust and Candor;464 16.3.2;Listen to the Facts;465 16.3.3;Technical Expertise;465 16.3.4;Root Cause Analysis;465 16.3.4.1;Difficulties with root cause;466 16.3.4.2;Ockhams Razor;467 16.3.5;Project Management;468 16.3.6;AttorneyClient Privilege;468 16.4;Blame and Fault Finding;468 16.4.1;Management Trust;469 16.4.2;Early Reporting of Bad News;469 16.4.3;Management Pressure;469 16.4.4;Safety as a Cause of Incidents;470 16.5;Communications;470 16.5.1;Technicians;470 16.5.2;Mid-Level Managers;471 16.5.3;Senior Managers;471 16.6;Definitions;471 16.6.1;Incident;471 16.6.2;Accident;472 16.6.3;Near Miss/Hit;472 16.6.4;Potential Incident;472 16.6.5;High Potential Incident;473 16.7;Incident Investigation Steps;473 16.7.1;Step 1Initial Investigation;474 16.7.2;Step 2Evaluation and Team Formation;474 16.7.3;Step 3Information Gathering;475 16.7.4;Step 4Timeline Development;476 16.7.5;Step 5Root Cause Analysis;476 16.7.6;Step 6Report and Recommendations;476 16.8;Step 1. Initial Investigation;476 16.8.1;The Go Team;476 16.8.1.1;Immediate actions;477 16.8.1.2;Team preparation;477 16.8.2;Drug and Alcohol Testing;478 16.8.3;Incident Report Form;478 16.8.3.1;Incident number;478 16.8.3.2;Title;479 16.8.3.3;Location, date, and time of event;480 16.8.3.4;Duration of event;480 16.8.3.5;Date and time of report;480 16.8.3.6;How observed;480 16.8.3.7;Person(s) reporting;480 16.8.3.8;Preliminary ranking;480 16.8.3.9;Incident type;480 16.8.3.10;Incident flags;480 16.8.3.11;First description of event;480 16.8.3.12;Immediate corrective actions taken;481 16.8.3.13;Witnesses;481 16.8.3.14;Contractor involvement;481 16.8.3.15;Detailed location;481 16.8.3.16;Consequences;481 16.8.3.17;Emergency response;482 16.8.3.18;Security issues;482 16.8.3.19;System alert;482 16.8.3.20;Incident owner/department;482 16.8.3.21;Notes and attachments;482 16.
8.4;First Management Report;482 16.9;Step 2. Evaluation and Team Formation;483 16.9.1;Evaluation;483 16.9.2;Team Formation;484 16.9.3;Outside Investigators;484 16.9.4;Corporate Support;485 16.9.5;Team Members;485 16.9.5.1;Sponsor;485 16.9.5.2;Incident owner;485 16.9.5.3;Facility manager;485 16.9.5.4;Lead investigator;486 16.9.5.5;Administrator;486 16.9.5.6;Area supervisor;486 16.9.5.7;HSE representative;487 16.9.5.8;PSM coordinator;487 16.9.5.9;Employee representative;487 16.9.5.10;Process/facilities engineer;487 16.9.5.11;Maintenance technicians;487 16.9.5.12;Subject matter experts;487 16.9.5.13;Contractors/vendors;487 16.9.5.14;Emergency response specialists;487 16.9.5.15;Attorneys;488 16.9.6;Charter/Terms of Reference;488 16.9.7;Team Member Qualifications;488 16.9.7.1;Objectivity;488 16.9.7.2;Common sense;488 16.9.7.3;Jumping to conclusions;489 16.9.7.4;Haughtiness and empathy;489 16.9.7.5;Understand incident investigation methodology;490 16.9.7.6;You do know what you dont know;490 16.9.7.7;Understand process systems;490 16.9.7.8;Logical thinking/painstaking;490 16.10;Step 3. Information Gathering;490 16.10.1;Interviews;491 16.10.2;Interview Guidelines;492 16.10.3;Regulatory/Legal Interviews;494 16.10.4;Witness Interviews;495 16.10.5;Interviewer Attributes;496 16.10.5.1;Rapport and trust;496 16.10.5.2;Technical skills;497 16.10.5.3;Critical factors recognition;497 16.10.5.4;Objective;497 16.10.5.5;Effective note taking;497 16.10.5.6;Management interviews;497 16.10.6;Documentation;497 16.10.7;Engineering Information;498 16.10.8;Operating Information;498 16.10.8.1;Instrument records;498 16.10.8.2;Log books, maintenance records, and JSAs;498 16.10.8.3;Hazards analysis reports;498 16.10.8.4;MOC records;498 16.10.8.5;Operating manuals/procedures;498 16.10.8.6;Incident investigations and audits;499 16.10.9;Vendor Data;499 16.10.10;Field Information;499 16.10.11;Damage Assessment;499 16.10.12;Photographs and DVDs;499 16.10.13;Closed Circuit Television;500 16.10.14;Instr
ument Records;500 16.10.15;Testing/Lab Analysis;500 16.11;Step 4. Timeline Development;500 16.11.1;Timeline Steps;501 16.11.1.1;Section 1Events prior to the incident;501 16.11.1.2;Section 2The incident;501 16.11.1.3;Section 3Postincident response;501 16.11.2;Timeline Construction;502 16.11.3;Conditions;503 16.11.4;Multiple Timelines;503 16.11.5;Timeline Table;505 16.11.6;Background Information;506 16.12;Step 5. Root Cause Analysis;506 16.12.1;Levels of Root Cause;507 16.12.1.1;Single incidents;508 16.12.1.2;Multiple incidents;508 16.12.2;Types of Root Cause Analysis;509 16.12.3;Argument by Analogy: Story Telling;509 16.12.3.1;False extrapolation;510 16.12.3.2;Linearity;510 16.12.3.3;World views;510 16.12.4;Safeguards;511 16.12.5;Management Action;511 16.12.6;Categorization;512 16.12.6.1;Equipment failure;512 16.12.6.2;Human error as a root cause;513 16.12.6.3;Process systems failure;513 16.12.7;System Analysis;513 16.12.8;Why Trees;513 16.12.8.1;Single chain of events;514 16.12.8.2;Wrong chain;514 16.12.9;Fault Tree Analysis;515 16.12.10;Linkage of Fault Trees to the Timeline;518 16.12.11;Common Cause Events;518 16.13;Step 6. Report and Recommendations;519 16.13.1;Levels of Recommendation;520 16.13.1.1;Short-term recommendations;520 16.13.1.2;Intermediate recommendations;520 16.13.1.3;Long-term recommendations;521 16.13.1.4;Industry guidance;521 16.13.2;Report Structure;521 16.13.2.1;Executive summary;521 16.13.2.2;What happened?;522 16.13.2.3;What could have happened?;522 16.13.2.4;What was the cause?;522 16.13.2.5;What actions should be taken?;522 16.13.2.6;Recognition;523 16.13.2.7;Terms of reference;523 16.13.2.8;Reason for selection;523 16.13.2.9;Sequence of events;523 16.13.2.10;Consequences;523 16.13.2.11;Root causes;524 16.13.2.12;Other hazards;524 16.13.2.13;Recommendations;524 16.13.2.14;Attachments;524 16.13.2.15;Attachment ARegulations and standards;524 16.13.2.16;Attachment BRoot cause analysis;524 16.13.2.17;Attachment COrganization chart;524 16.13.2.1
8;Attachment DReview of similar events;524 16.13.2.19;Attachment EInvestigation team;525 16.13.2.20;Attachment FReview of modern designs;525 16.13.2.21;Attachment GIndex to pictures and documents;525 16.13.2.22;Attachment HDetailed timeline;525 16.13.3;Issuing the Report;525 16.13.3.1;Writing the report;525 16.13.3.2;Presenting the report;525 16.13.3.3;Follow-up and recommendations tracking;526 16.13.3.4;Legal issues;526 16.14;Information Security and Chain of Custody;527 16.14.1;Record Retention;527 16.14.2;Removing Evidence;527 16.14.3;File Systems;527 16.14.4;Incident/Risk Register;529 16.15;Feedback;530 16.16;Incident Databases;530 16.16.1;National Response Center;531 16.16.2;Accidental Release Information Program (ARIP) Database;531 16.16.3;Census of Fatal Occupational Injuries (CFOI);532 16.16.4;Major Accident Reporting System (MARS);532 16.16.5;Marsh and McLENNAN Reviews;533 16.16.6;Annual Loss Prevention Symposia;533 16.16.7;Process Safety Beacon;533 16.16.8;Government Agencies;533 17;12 Emergency Management;534 17.1;Introduction;534 17.2;Abnormal Situation Management;535 17.3;Human Response;536 17.3.1;Human Error Rate;536 17.3.2;Fixation;536 17.3.3;Heroism and Buddy Loyalty;537 17.4;Troubleshooting;537 17.5;Levels of Emergency;538 17.5.1;Cause of Emergency;538 17.5.2;Emergency Operations;539 17.5.3;Local Emergency Response;540 17.5.4;General Emergency Response;540 17.5.5;Recovery Operations;541 17.5.6;Investigation and Follow-Up;541 17.6;Emergency Planning;541 17.6.1;Organization and Personnel;541 17.6.2;Emergency Response Manual;541 17.6.3;Emergency Procedures;543 17.6.4;Emergency Response Training;543 17.6.5;Communications;544 17.7;Emergency Shutdown;545 17.7.1;ESD Hierarchy;545 17.7.2;Shutdown Zones;545 17.7.3;System Reset;546 17.8;Fire and Gas Detection;547 17.8.1;Fire Detection;547 17.8.2;Fire Eyes/Flame Detectors;547 17.8.3;Smoke Detectors;548 17.8.4;Heat Detectors;549 17.8.5;Fusible Links;549 17.8.6;Low Oxygen Detectors;549 17.8.7;Combustible Gas Det
ectors;549 17.8.8;Manual Call Points;550 17.8.9;Toxic Gas Releases;550 17.9;Escape Routes;550 17.10;Firefighting;551 17.10.1;Single Fire Concept;551 17.10.2;Deluge Systems;551 17.10.3;Fire Zones;551 18;13 Audits and Assessments;553 18.1;Introduction;553 18.2;Formal Audits;555 18.2.1;Reasons for Audits;556 18.2.1.1;Accident follow-up;556 18.2.1.2;Regulatory/standards compliance;556 18.2.1.3;Stakeholder outreach;556 18.2.1.4;Voluntary check;556 18.2.1.5;Insurance and business security;557 18.2.2;Audit Standards;557 18.2.2.1;Regulations;557 18.2.2.2;Reporting requirements;557 18.2.2.3;Industry standards;558 18.2.2.4;Internal standards;558 18.2.3;Audit Frequency;558 18.2.4;Audit Personnel;558 18.2.4.1;Outside auditors;559 18.2.4.2;Internal auditors;559 18.2.4.3;Team composition;560 18.2.5;Auditor Attributes;560 18.2.5.1;Audit service providers;560 18.2.5.2;Interview skills;561 18.2.5.3;Technical knowledge;561 18.2.5.4;Writing skills;561 18.2.5.5;Demeanor;561 18.2.6;The Host Company;562 18.2.6.1;First impressions;562 18.2.6.2;Employees;563 18.2.7;Planning the Audit;563 18.2.7.1;Goals;563 18.2.7.2;Determine the audit standard;564 18.2.7.3;Scope;564 18.2.7.4;Budget;565 18.2.7.5;Schedule;565 18.2.7.6;One-point contact;566 18.2.7.7;Preaudit activities;566 18.2.8;Audit Forms;566 18.2.9;Conducting the Audit;567 18.2.9.1;Auditor preparation;568 18.2.9.2;Kick-off meeting;568 18.2.9.3;Plant tour;569 18.2.9.4;Information collection;569 18.2.9.5;Role of personnel;569 18.2.9.6;Interviews;569 18.2.9.7;On-site inspection;570 18.2.9.8;Closeout meeting;571 18.2.10;Report;571 18.2.10.1;Draft report;571 18.2.10.2;Generalities;572 18.2.10.3;Report distribution;572 18.2.10.4;Letter of certification;572 18.2.10.5;Audit verification;572 18.2.10.6;Positive findings;573 18.2.10.7;Report retention;573 18.2.11;Findings;574 18.2.12;Follow-Up;574 18.2.13;Unannounced Audits;574 18.3;The SEMS Audit Rule;575 18.4;SEMS II;582 18.4.1;Audit Requirements;582 18.4.2;Independent Third-Party Auditors;584 18.
4.3;I3P Qualifications;584 18.5;National Emphasis Program;585 18.6;Reviews and Expert Assessments;585 18.6.1;Review Issues;586 18.6.1.1;Management systems effectiveness;586 18.6.1.2;Workforce involvement;587 18.6.1.3;Real-world usefulness;587 18.6.1.4;Learned to live with it problems;587 18.6.1.5;Lessons learned;587 18.6.2;Reviewer Attributes;587 18.7;Management Elements Assessment;588 18.7.1;Level 1: Risk Management;589 18.7.2;Level 2: Management Element Spreadsheet;589 18.7.3;Level 3: Detailed Questions;591 18.7.4;Scoring Template;592 18.7.5;Guidance;593 18.7.6;Benefits of the Elements Assessment Approach;593 18.7.6.1;Independent of events;593 18.7.6.2;Handling abstraction;594 18.7.6.3;Smoothing of results;594 18.7.6.4;Objectivity;594 19;14 Consequence Analysis;595 19.1;Introduction;595 19.2;Range of Consequences;596 19.2.1;Safety;597 19.2.2;Health;598 19.2.3;Environmental;598 19.2.4;Economic;598 19.2.5;Effect of a Release;598 19.3;Hole Size;599 19.4;Fires;599 19.4.1;Flammable Range;599 19.4.2;Ignition Temperature/Energy;600 19.4.3;Spontaneous Combustion;601 19.4.4;Ignition Sources;602 19.4.4.1;Vacuum trucks;602 19.4.4.2;Radiant heat;602 19.4.4.3;Static electricity;602 19.4.4.4;Lightning;603 19.4.4.5;Pyrophorics/iron sulfide;604 19.4.5;Flammability Hazard Ranking;604 19.4.6;Passive Fire Protection/Fireproofing;604 19.5;Explosions;605 19.5.1;Physical Explosions;606 19.5.2;Vapor Cloud Explosions;606 19.5.3;Deflagrations and Detonations;606 19.5.4;Blast Effects;607 19.5.5;BLEVEs;607 19.5.6;Dust Explosions;608 19.6;Toxic Gas Releases;608 19.6.1;Gas Release Modeling;608 19.6.2;Effect of Toxic Gases;610 19.6.3;Probit Equations;611 19.6.4;Short-Term Exposure Limits;611 19.6.4.1;Emergency response planning guidelines;612 19.6.4.2;Immediately dangerous to life and health;613 19.6.4.3;Permissible exposure limits;613 19.6.4.4;Threshold limit values;614 19.6.4.5;Short-term exposure limit;614 19.6.4.6;Levels of concern (EPA);615 19.6.4.7;Acutely toxic concentration/levels (New
Jersey/Delaware);615 19.6.4.8;Substance hazards index;615 19.6.5;Location of Monitors;616 20;15 Frequency Analysis;617 20.1;Introduction;617 20.2;The Pareto Principle;618 20.3;Importance Ranking;618 20.4;Fault Tree Analysis;619 20.4.1;Gates;621 20.4.1.1;OR Gate;621 20.4.1.2;AND Gate;622 20.4.1.3;VOTING Gate;626 20.4.2;Events;627 20.4.2.1;Top Event;627 20.4.2.2;Intermediate Events;628 20.4.2.3;Base Events;628 20.4.2.4;House Event;629 20.4.3;Top-Down Development of a Fault Tree;629 20.4.3.1;1. Define the Top Event;630 20.4.3.2;2. Build the Tree;630 20.4.3.3;3. Identify the Cut Sets;633 20.4.3.4;4. Eliminate Repeat Sets;637 20.4.3.5;5. Eliminate Repeat Events in a Set;638 20.4.3.6;6. Eliminate Redundant Events;638 20.4.3.7;7. Quantify the Risk;640 20.4.3.8;Mathematics of an OR Gate;640 20.4.3.9;Mathematics of an AND Gate;641 20.4.3.10;Mathematics of a Voting Gate;642 20.4.3.11;Cut Set quantification;642 20.4.3.12;8. Risk Rank;643 20.4.3.13;Event contribution;643 20.4.3.14;Important few;644 20.4.3.15;Unimportant many;644 20.4.3.16;Power of the AND Gate;645 20.4.3.17;Importance equalization;645 20.4.3.18;Costbenefit analysis;645 20.4.4;Importance Ranking Using Cut Sets;645 20.4.4.1;Birnbaum factor method;645 20.4.4.2;FussellVesely method;646 20.4.4.3;Perturbation method;646 20.4.5;Common Cause Events;646 20.4.6;Fukushima-Daiichi;647 20.4.7;Generic Fault Trees;648 20.4.7.1;Generic safety fault tree;649 20.4.7.2;Generic reliability fault tree;652 20.4.8;Discussion of the Fault Tree Method;652 20.4.9;Qualitative FTA;653 20.5;Event Tree Analysis;653 20.5.1;Quantification of an Event Tree;654 20.5.2;Scope of Event;657 20.5.3;Combining Event Trees and Fault Trees;657 20.5.4;Short Sequence of Events;658 20.5.5;Many Events;658 20.5.6;Partial Success;659 20.6;Discrete Event Analysis;659 20.6.1;Nonlinearities and Complexities;659 20.6.2;Conveying Statistical Uncertainty;660 20.7;Monte Carlo Simulation;660 20.7.1;Random Number Generators;660 20.7.2;Seed Numbers;661 20.7.3;Speeding
the Simulation;661 20.8;Markov Models;661 20.9;Top-Down/Bottom-Up Approach;664 20.9.1;Top-Down;664 20.9.2;Bottom-Up;664 20.9.3;Qualitative Insights;664 20.10;Limitations to Quantification;665 20.10.1;Mathematical Understanding;665 20.10.2;Value-Laden Assumptions;666 20.10.3;Lack of Exhaustivity;666 20.10.4;Human Behavior;666 20.10.5;Data Quality;666 20.11;Safeguards;667 20.11.1;Safeguard Level 1: Normal Operations;668 20.11.2;Safeguard Level 2: Procedural Safeguards;669 20.11.3;Safeguard Level 3: Safety Instrumented Systems;669 20.11.4;Safeguard Level 4: Mechanical Safeguards;670 20.11.5;Safeguard Level 5: Passive Safeguards;670 20.11.6;Safeguard Level 6: Emergency Response;670 20.12;Layer of Protection Analysis;670 20.12.1;The LOPA Process;671 20.12.2;Single Scenarios;672 20.12.3;IPLs;672 20.12.3.1;Specific;673 20.12.3.2;Independent;673 20.12.3.3;Dependable;673 20.12.3.4;Auditable;674 20.12.4;Human Response;674 20.12.5;Implementing LOPA;674 20.12.5.1;Team makeup;674 20.12.5.2;Timing;674 20.12.5.3;Tools;674 20.12.5.4;Procedures and inspections;674 20.12.5.5;Risk criteria;675 20.13;Failure Rate Data;675 20.14;Conditional Probability/Bayes Theorem;675 20.14.1;Evaluation of Tests;676 20.14.2;Sequential Observations;677 20.14.3;Combining Data Sources;677 21;16 Reliability, Availability, and Maintainability;682 21.1;Introduction;682 21.2;Benefits of a RAM Program;684 21.2.1;Increased Production and Profitability;684 21.2.2;Increased Productivity;685 21.2.3;Reduced Investment;685 21.2.4;Lower Maintenance Costs;686 21.2.5;Lower Inventories;686 21.2.6;Enhanced Customer Satisfaction;686 21.2.7;Personal Recognition;686 21.2.8;Personal Life;686 21.2.9;Improved Public Perception;686 21.3;Reliability and Safety;687 21.3.1;Hazardous Operations;687 21.3.2;Unsafe Process Conditions;687 21.3.3;Safety Bypasses;687 21.3.4;Transient Stresses;687 21.3.5;Reduced Chance of Catastrophic Losses;687 21.3.6;Increased Safety May Reduce Reliability;687 21.3.7;Loss of Experience;688 21.3.8;Engi
neering Practices;688 21.3.9;Daily Operations;688 21.4;Definitions;688 21.4.1;Reliability;688 21.4.2;Availability;689 21.4.3;Effectiveness;690 21.4.4;Maintainability;690 21.5;Failure Modes;691 21.5.1;Equipment Description;691 21.5.2;Primary, Secondary, and Command Failures;691 21.5.3;Catastrophic, Degraded, and Incipient Failures;692 21.5.4;Real Failures/Necessary Replacements;692 21.6;Failure Rates;692 21.6.1;Constant/Exponential Distribution;694 21.6.2;Lognormal Distribution;694 21.6.3;Bathtub Curve;694 21.6.3.1;Early failures;695 21.6.3.2;Constant failure rate;695 21.6.3.3;Wear-out failures;696 21.6.4;Reliability Block Diagrams;696 21.6.5;Active/Standby Redundancy;698 21.6.6;Quantification of Block Diagrams;698 21.7;Human Reliability;700 21.7.1;Types of Human Error;701 21.7.1.1;Errors of intent;701 21.7.1.2;Mistakes;701 21.7.1.3;Slips;701 21.7.1.4;Fixation;702 21.7.1.5;Error in an emergency;702 21.7.1.6;Incorrect response;702 21.7.2;Human Reliability Analysis;702 21.7.3;THERP;703 22;17 Managing a Risk Program;704 22.1;Introduction;704 22.2;Clients/Customers;704 22.2.1;Senior Management;704 22.2.2;Facility Managers;705 22.2.3;Project Managers and Design Engineers;705 22.2.4;Regulators/Auditors;705 22.3;Program Organization;705 22.3.1;Step 1Determine the Objectives;706 22.3.2;Step 2Set Up an Organization;706 22.3.2.1;Management;706 22.3.2.2;Steering committee;706 22.3.2.3;Coordinator;707 22.3.2.4;Subcommittees;708 22.3.2.5;Operating binders;708 22.3.3;Step 3Create the Metrics and Baseline;710 22.3.4;Step 4Develop a Plan;711 22.3.4.1;Goals;712 22.3.4.2;Resources needed;712 22.3.4.3;Develop a schedule;712 22.3.4.4;Reviews and signatures;713 22.3.5;Step 5Implement the Plan;713 22.3.6;Step 6Audit/Improve;714 23;18 Project Management;715 23.1;Introduction;715 23.2;Phase/Gate System;715 23.3;Hazards Analysis on Projects;716 23.4;Phase IConcept Selection;718 23.4.1;Documents;719 23.4.2;Hazards Analysis;719 23.5;Phase IIPreliminary Design (FEED);720 23.5.1;Documents;720 23
.5.2;Hazards Analysis;721 23.6;Phase IIIDetailed Engineering;722 23.6.1;Documents;722 23.6.2;Hazards Analysis;722 23.7;Phase IVFabrication and Construction;722 23.7.1;Precommissioning;723 23.7.2;Punch lists;723 23.7.3;Transfer of Care, Custody, and Control;724 23.7.4;Documents;724 23.7.4.1;Turnover packages;724 23.7.4.2;Procedures;727 23.7.5;Hazards Analysis;727 23.8;Phase VCommissioning and Start-Up;727 23.8.1;Commissioning;727 23.8.2;Operational Readiness Review;727 23.8.3;Start-up and Line Out;728 23.8.4;Documents;729 23.8.4.1;Start-up procedures;729 23.8.4.2;Acceptance test;729 23.8.4.3;Warranty;729 23.8.5;Hazards Analysis;729 23.9;Project Organization;729 24;19 Contractors;731 24.1;Introduction;731 24.2;Regulations and Standards;733 24.2.1;OSHA PSM Standard;733 24.2.2;OSHA PSM Guidance;734 24.2.2.1;Application;735 24.2.2.2;Employer responsibilities;735 24.2.3;BSEE SEMS;735 24.2.4;API RP 76;736 24.3;Types of Contractor;736 24.3.1;Contract Companies;738 24.3.1.1;Selecting a contract company;738 24.3.1.2;Contractor HSE program;739 24.3.2;Design Companies;740 24.3.3;Subcontractors;740 24.3.4;Contract Workers;740 24.3.5;Maintenance Contractors;741 24.3.6;Visitors/Consultants;741 24.4;Bridging Documents;741 24.4.1;Operator/Contractor Bridging Document;741 24.4.2;Bridging Through a Regulation;742 24.5;Contractor Management;743 24.5.1;Contractor Selection;743 24.5.2;Record Keeping;744 24.5.3;Contractor Training;744 24.5.4;Safety Meetings;744 24.5.5;USE OF Equipment;745 24.5.6;Contractor Evaluation;745 24.5.7;Infractions;746 24.5.8;Contractor Training;746 24.5.9;Safety Meetings;746 25;20 The Risk Management Professional;748 25.1;Introduction;748 25.2;Attributes;749 25.2.1;Education and Certification;749 25.2.2;Technical Knowledge;749 25.2.3;Holistic;749 25.2.4;Numerate;750 25.2.5;Communication Skills;750 25.2.6;Industrial Experience;750 25.2.7;Knowledge of Past Events;750 25.2.8;Professional Involvement;751 25.2.9;Network;751 25.2.10;The Resumé/CV;751 25.2.10.1;Level of
detail;751 25.2.10.2;Publications;752 25.2.10.3;Gaps/negative facts;752 25.2.10.4;Multiple resumés;752 25.2.10.5;Declining experience;752 25.2.11;Professional Engineer;752 25.3;Consultants;753 25.3.1;True Expertise;753 25.3.2;The Consultant as Outsider;753 25.3.3;ConsultantsNot Contractors;754 25.3.4;Cuts Gordian Knots;755 25.3.5;Quick Study;755 25.3.6;Role of the Client;755 25.3.7;Response to Criticism;756 25.3.8;Marketing;756 25.4;Communicating with Management/Clients;756 25.4.1;Presentations;756 25.4.2;Meetings;757 25.5;Report Writing;757 25.5.1;Draft Report;758 25.5.2;Language of the Report;759 25.5.3;Completeness/Thoroughness;759 25.5.4;Personal Information;759 25.5.5;Writing Style;759 25.5.5.1;Nonemotional language;760 25.5.5.2;Minimalist writingMake every word tell;760 25.5.5.3;Omit needless words/tautologies;760 25.5.5.4;Short, simple words;760 25.5.5.5;Minimize soft materials;761 25.5.5.6;Eschew obfuscation;761 25.5.5.7;Develop a theme;761 25.5.5.8;Modifiers;762 25.5.5.9;No typos;763 25.5.5.10;Date format;763 25.5.5.11;Active/passive voice;763 25.5.5.12;He/she;763 25.5.5.13;You/I;764 25.5.5.14;Choice of words;764 25.5.5.15;Use of humor;764 25.5.6;Copyright;765 25.5.7;Responsible Document Creation;765 25.6;Anecdotes/Storytelling;766 25.6.1;Stories;767 25.6.2;Elements of a Story;767 25.6.2.1;Characters;767 25.6.2.2;Setting;767 25.6.2.3;Plot;767 25.6.2.4;Conflict;768 25.6.2.5;Resolution;768 25.6.3;Sensitivity;768 25.7;Communicating with the Public;768 25.7.1;The Community;769 25.7.2;Other Businesses;770 25.7.3;The Media;770 25.7.4;Regulators/Nongovernmental Organizations;770 25.7.5;Types of Public Communication;770 25.7.6;Developing a Risk Communication Program;771 25.7.7;Communicating New Paradigms;771 25.8;Trade Secrets (OSHA);771 25.9;Litigation Support;775 25.9.1;Use of Legal Services;775 25.9.2;Types of Litigation;776 25.9.3;The Participants;776 25.9.4;Timeline/Story Line;776 25.9.5;Documentation;776 25.9.6;The Discovery Process;777 25.9.7;Depositions;77
7 25.9.8;Witnesses to Fact;778 25.10;The Expert Witness;778 25.10.1;Acceptance by the Court;779 25.10.2;Daubert and Frye Rules;780 25.10.3;Prior Testimony;780 25.10.4;Timeline/Story Line;780 25.10.5;The Report;780 25.10.6;Attributes of an Expert Witness;781 25.10.6.1;To thine own self be true;781 25.10.6.2;Be prepared;781 25.10.6.3;Be a true expert;781 25.10.6.4;Be a teacher;781 25.10.6.5;Reasonable risk;782 25.10.7;Privilege;782 26;References;784 27;Index;788