A practical introduction to epidemiology, biostatistics, and research methodology for the whole health care community This comprehensive text, which has been extensively revised with new material and additional topics, utilizes a practical slant to introduce health professionals and students to epidemiology, biostatistics, and research methodology. It draws examples from a wide range of topics, covering all of the main contemporary health research methods, including survival analysis, Cox regression, and systematic reviews and meta-analysis--the explanation of which go beyond introductory concepts. This second edition of Quantitative Methods for Health Research: A Practical Interactive Guide to Epidemiology and Statistics also helps develop critical skills that will prepare students to move on to more advanced and specialized methods. A clear distinction is made between knowledge and concepts that all students should ensure they understand, and those that can be pursued further by those who wish to do so. Self-assessment exercises throughout the text help students explore and reflect on their understanding. A program of practical exercises in SPSS (using a prepared data set) helps to consolidate the theory and develop skills and confidence in data handling, analysis, and interpretation. Highlights of the book include:
- Combining epidemiology and bio-statistics to demonstrate the relevance and strength of statistical methods
- Emphasis on the interpretation of statistics using examples from a variety of public health and health care situations to stress relevance and application
- Use of concepts related to examples of published research to show the application of methods and balance between ideals and the realities of research in practice
- Integration of practical data analysis exercises to develop skills and confidence
- Supplementation by a student companion website which provides guidance on data handling in SPSS and study data sets as referred to in the text
Quantitative Methods for Health Research, Second Edition is a practical learning resource for students, practitioners and researchers in public health, health care and related disciplines, providing both a course book and a useful introductory reference.
Inhaltsverzeichnis
Preface xv
About the Companion Website xxi
1 Philosophy of Science and Introduction to Epidemiology 1
Introduction and Learning Objectives 1
1. 1 Approaches to Scientific Research 2
1. 1. 1 History and Nature of Scientific Research 2
1. 1. 2 What is Epidemiology? 6
1. 1. 3 What are Statistics? 7
1. 1. 4 Approach to Learning 8
1. 2 Formulating a Research Question 8
1. 2. 1 Importance of a Well-Defined Research Question 8
1. 2. 2 Development of Research Ideas 10
1. 3 Rates: Incidence and Prevalence 11
1. 3. 1 Why Do We Need Rates? 11
1. 3. 2 Measures of Disease Frequency 12
1. 3. 3 Prevalence Rate 12
1. 3. 4 Incidence Rate 12
1. 3. 5 Relationship Between Incidence, Duration, and Prevalence 15
1. 4 Concepts of Prevention 16
1. 4. 1 Introduction 16
1. 4. 2 Primary, Secondary, and Tertiary Prevention 17
1. 5 Answers to Self-Assessment Exercises 18
2 Routine Data Sources and Descriptive Epidemiology 25
Introduction and Learning Objectives 25
2. 1 Routine Collection of Health Information 26
2. 1. 1 Deaths (Mortality) 26
2. 1. 2 Compiling Mortality Statistics: The Example of England and Wales 28
2. 1. 3 Suicide Among Men 29
2. 1. 4 Suicide Among Young Women 31
2. 1. 5 Variations in Deaths of Very Young Children 31
2. 2 Descriptive Epidemiology 33
2. 2. 1 What is Descriptive Epidemiology? 33
2. 2. 2 International Variations in Rates of Lung Cancer 33
2. 2. 3 Illness (Morbidity) 34
2. 2. 4 Sources of Information on Morbidity 35
2. 2. 5 Notification of Infectious Disease 35
2. 2. 6 Illness Seen in General Practice 38
2. 3 Information on the Environment 39
2. 3. 1 Air Pollution and Health 39
2. 3. 2 Routinely Available Data on Air Pollution 39
2. 4 Displaying, Describing, and Presenting Data 41
2. 4. 1 Displaying the Data 41
2. 4. 2 Calculating the Frequency Distribution 42
2. 4. 3 Describing the Frequency Distribution 44
2. 4. 4 The Relative Frequency Distribution 57
2. 4. 5 Scatterplots, Linear Relationships and Correlation 60
2. 5 Routinely Available Health Data 69
2. 5. 1 Introduction 69
2. 5. 2 Classification of Routine Health Information Sources 69
2. 5. 3 Demographic Data 71
2. 5. 4 Health Event Data 73
2. 5. 5 Population-Based Health Information 78
2. 5. 6 Deprivation Indices 79
2. 5. 7 Routine Data Sources for Countries Other Than the UK 80
2. 6 Descriptive Epidemiology in Action 80
2. 6. 1 The London Smogs of the 1950s 80
2. 6. 2 Ecological Studies 82
2. 7 Overview of Epidemiological Study Designs 84
2. 8 Answers to Self-Assessment Exercises 86
3 Standardisation 101
Introduction and Learning Objectives 101
3. 1 Health Inequalities in Merseyside 101
3. 1. 1 Socio-Economic Conditions and Health 101
3. 1. 2 Comparison of Crude Death Rates 102
3. 1. 3 Usefulness of a Summary Measure 104
3. 2 Indirect Standardisation: Calculation of the Standardised Mortality Ratio (SMR) 105
3. 2. 1 Mortality in Liverpool 105
3. 2. 2 Interpretation of the SMR 107
3. 2. 3 Dealing With Random Variation: The 95 per cent Confidence Interval 107
3. 2. 4 Increasing Precision of the SMR Estimate 108
3. 2. 5 Mortality in Sefton 108
3. 2. 6 Comparison of SMRs 110
3. 2. 7 Indirectly Standardised Mortality Rates 110
3. 3 Direct Standardisation 110
3. 3. 1 Introduction 110
3. 3. 2 An Example: Changes in Deaths From Stroke Over Time 111
3. 3. 3 Using the European Standard Population 112
3. 3. 4 Direct or Indirect: Which Method is Best? 113
3. 4 Standardisation for Factors Other Than Age 114
3. 5 Answers to Self-Assessment Exercises 115
4 Surveys 123
Introduction and Learning Objectives 123
Resource Papers 124
4. 1 Purpose and Context 124
4. 1. 1 Defining the Research Question 124
4. 1. 2 Political Context of Research 126
4. 2 Sampling Methods 127
4. 2. 1 Introduction 127
4. 2. 2 Sampling 127
4. 2. 3 Probability 129
4. 2. 4 Simple Random Sampling 130
4. 2. 5 Stratified Sampling 131
4. 2. 6 Cluster Random Sampling 132
4. 2. 7 Multistage Random Sampling 133
4. 2. 8 Systematic Sampling 133
4. 2. 9 Convenience Sampling 133
4. 2. 10 Sampling People Who are Difficult to Contact 133
4. 2. 11 Quota Sampling 134
4. 2. 12 Sampling in Natsal- 3 135
4. 3 The Sampling Frame 137
4. 3. 1 Why Do We Need a Sampling Frame? 137
4. 3. 2 Losses in Sampling 137
4. 4 Sampling Error, Confidence Intervals, and Sample Size 139
4. 4. 1 Sampling Distributions and the Standard Error 139
4. 4. 2 The Standard Error 140
4. 4. 3 Key Properties of the Normal Distribution 145
4. 4. 4 Confidence Interval (CI) for the Sample Mean 146
4. 4. 5 Estimating Sample Size 149
4. 4. 6 Sample Size for Estimating a Population Mean 149
4. 4. 7 StandardErrorand95percentCIforaPopulationProportion 150
4. 4. 8 Sample Size to Estimate a Population Proportion 151
4. 5 Response 153
4. 5. 1 Determining the Response Rate 153
4. 5. 2 Assessing Whether the Sample is Representative 154
4. 5. 3 Maximising the Response Rate 154
4. 6 Measurement 157
4. 6. 1 Introduction: The Importance of Good Measurement 157
4. 6. 2 Interview or Self-Completed Questionnaire? 157
4. 6. 3 Principles of Good Questionnaire Design 158
4. 6. 4 Development of a Questionnaire 161
4. 6. 5 Checking How Well the Interviews and Questionnaires Have Worked 161
4. 6. 6 Assessing Measurement Quality 165
4. 6. 7 Overview of Sources of Error 169
4. 7 Data Types and Presentation 171
4. 7. 1 Introduction 171
4. 7. 2 Types of Data 172
4. 7. 3 Displaying and Summarising the Data 173
4. 8 Answers to Self-Assessment Exercises 176
5 Cohort Studies 185
Introduction and Learning Objectives 185
Resource Papers 186
5. 1 Why Do a Cohort Study? 186
5. 1. 1 Objectives of the Study 186
5. 1. 2 Study Structure 188
5. 2 Obtaining the Sample 188
5. 2. 1 Introduction 188
5. 2. 2 Sample Size 190
5. 3 Measurement 190
5. 3. 1 Importance of Good Measurement 190
5. 3. 2 Identifying and Avoiding Measurement Error 190
5. 3. 3 The Measurement of Blood Pressure 191
5. 3. 4 Case Definition 192
5. 4 Follow-Up 193
5. 4. 1 Nature of the Task 193
5. 4. 2 Deaths (Mortality) 193
5. 4. 3 Non-Fatal Cases (Morbidity) 194
5. 4. 4 Challenges Faced with Follow-Up of a Cohort in a Different Setting 194
5. 4. 5 Assessment of Changes During Follow-Up Period 196
5. 5 Basic Presentation and Analysis of Results 198
5. 5. 1 Initial Presentation of Findings 198
5. 5. 2 Relative Risk 199
5. 5. 3 Hypothesis Test for Categorical Data: The Chi-Squared Test 201
5. 5. 4 Hypothesis Tests for Continuous Data: The z-Test and the t-Test 209
5. 6 How Large Should a Cohort Study Be? 214
5. 6. 1 Perils of Inadequate Sample Size 214
5. 6. 2 Sample Size for a Cohort Study 215
5. 6. 3 Example of Output from Sample Size Calculation 216
5. 7 Assessing Whether an Association is Causal 218
5. 7. 1 The Hill Viewpoints 218
5. 7. 2 Confounding: What Is It and How Can It Be Addressed? 220
5. 7. 3 Does Smoking Cause Heart Disease? 222
5. 7. 4 Confounding in the Physical Activity and Cancer Study 222
5. 7. 5 Methods for Dealing with Confounding 224
5. 8 Simple Linear Regression 224
5. 8. 1 Approaches to Describing Associations 224
5. 8. 2 Finding the Best Fit for a Straight Line 226
5. 8. 3 Interpreting the Regression Line 227
5. 8. 4 Using the Regression Line 228
5. 8. 5 Hypothesis Test of the Association Between the Explanatory and Outcome Variables 228
5. 8. 6 How Good is the Regression Model? 229
5. 8. 7 Interpreting SPSS Output for Simple Linear Regression Analysis 231
5. 8. 8 First Table: Variables Entered/Removed 232
5. 9 Introduction to Multiple Linear Regression 235
5. 9. 1 Principles of Multiple Regression 235
5. 9. 2 Using Multivariable Linear Regression to Study Independent Associations 235
5. 9. 3 Investigation of the Effect of Work Stress on Bodyweight 235
5. 9. 4 Multiple Regression in the Cancer Study 239
5. 9. 5 Overview of Regression Methods for Different Types of Outcome 240
5. 10 Answers to Self-Assessment Exercises 242
6 Case-Control Studies 251
Introduction and Learning Objectives 251
Resource Papers 252
6. 1 Why do a Case-Control Study? 253
6. 1. 1 Study Objectives 253
6. 1. 2 Study Structure 254
6. 1. 3 Approach to Analysis 255
6. 1. 4 Retrospective Data Collection 257
6. 1. 5 Applications of the Case-Control Design 258
6. 2 Key Elements of Study Design 259
6. 2. 1 Selecting the Cases 259
6. 2. 2 The Controls 260
6. 2. 3 Exposure Assessment 262
6. 2. 4 Bias in Exposure Assessment 263
6. 3 Basic Unmatched and Matched Analysis 265
6. 3. 1 The Odds Ratio (OR) 265
6. 3. 2 Calculation of the OR-Simple Matched Analysis 269
6. 3. 3 Hypothesis Tests for Case-Control Studies 271
6. 4 Sample Size for a Case-Control Study 273
6. 4. 1 Introduction 273
6. 4. 2 What Information is Required? 273
6. 4. 3 An Example of Sample Size Calculation Using OpenEpi 274
6. 5 Confounding and Logistic Regression 276
6. 5. 1 Introduction 276
6. 5. 2 Stratification 277
6. 5. 3 Logistic Regression 278
6. 5. 4 Example: Multivariable Logistic Regression 281
6. 5. 5 Matched Studies - Conditional Logistic Regression 287
6. 5. 6 Interpretation of Adjusted Results from the New Zealand Study 287
6. 6 Answers to Self-Assessment Exercises 289
7 Intervention Studies 297
Introduction and Learning Objectives 297
Typology of Intervention Study Designs Described in This Chapter 297
Terminology 298
Resource Papers 299
7. 1 Why Do an Intervention Study? 299
7. 1. 1 Study Objectives 299
7. 1. 2 Structure of a Randomised, Controlled Intervention Study 300
7. 2 Key Elements of Intervention Study Design 303
7. 2. 1 Defining Who Should be Included and Excluded 303
7. 2. 2 Intervention and Control 304
7. 2. 3 Randomisation 306
7. 2. 4 Outcome Assessment 307
7. 2. 5 Blinding 308
7. 2. 6 Ethical Issues for Intervention Studies 308
7. 3 The Analysis of Intervention Studies 309
7. 3. 1 Review of Variables at Baseline 310
7. 3. 2 Loss to Follow-Up 311
7. 3. 3 Compliance with the Treatment Allocation 311
7. 3. 4 Analysis by Intention-to-Treat 312
7. 3. 5 Analysis per Protocol 313
7. 3. 6 What is the Effect of the Intervention? 313
7. 3. 7 Drawing Conclusions 315
7. 3. 8 Adjustment for Variables Known to Influence the Outcome 315
7. 3. 9 Paired Comparisons 315
7. 3. 10 The Crossover Trial 317
7. 4 Testing More-Complex Interventions 318
7. 4. 1 Introduction 318
7. 4. 2 Randomised Trial of Individuals for a Complex Intervention 319
7. 4. 3 Factorial Design 322
7. 4. 4 Analysis and Interpretation 323
7. 4. 5 Departure from the Ideal Blinded RCT Design 327
7. 4. 6 The Cluster Randomised Trial 328
7. 4. 7 The Community (Cluster) Randomised Trial 330
7. 4. 8 Non-Randomised Intervention Designs 332
7. 4. 9 The Natural Experiment 333
7. 5 Analysis of Intervention Studies Using a Cluster Design 334
7. 5. 1 Why Does the Use of Clusters Make a Difference? 334
7. 5. 2 Summarising Clustering Effects: The Intra-Class Correlation Coefficient 334
7. 5. 3 Multi-Level Modelling 335
7. 5. 4 Analysis of the Cluster RCT of Physical Activity 335
7. 6 How Big Should the Intervention Study Be? 337
7. 6. 1 Introduction 337
7. 6. 2 Sample Size for a Trial with Categorical Data Outcomes 337
7. 6. 3 One-Sided and Two-Sided Tests 339
7. 6. 4 Sample Size for a Trial with Continuous Data Outcomes 339
7. 6. 5 Sample Size for an Intervention Study Using Cluster Design 340
7. 6. 6 Estimation of Sample Size is not a Precise Science 341
7. 7 Intervention Study Registration, Management, and Reporting 341
7. 7. 1 Introduction 341
7. 7. 2 Registration 342
7. 7. 3 Trial Management 342
7. 7. 4 Reporting Standards (CONSORT) 343
7. 8 Answers to Self-Assessment Exercises 344
8 Life Tables, Survival Analysis, and Cox Regression 355
Introduction and Learning Objectives 355
Resource Papers 356
8. 1 Survival Analysis 356
8. 1. 1 Introduction 356
8. 1. 2 Why Do We Need Survival Analysis? 356
8. 1. 3 Censoring 357
8. 1. 4 Kaplan-Meier Survival Curves 359
8. 1. 5 Kaplan-Meier Survival Curves 361
8. 1. 6 The Log-Rank Test 362
8. 1. 7 Interpretation of the Kaplan-Meier Survival Curve 365
8. 2 Cox Regression 371
8. 2. 1 Introduction 371
8. 2. 2 The Hazard Function 371
8. 2. 3 Assumption of Proportional Hazards 372
8. 2. 4 The Cox Regression Model 372
8. 2. 5 Checking the Assumption of Proportional Hazards 372
8. 2. 6 Interpreting the Cox Regression Model 373
8. 2. 7 Prediction 374
8. 2. 8 Application of Cox Regression 375
8. 3 Current Life Tables 377
8. 3. 1 Introduction 377
8. 3. 2 Current Life Tables and Life Expectancy at Birth 377
8. 3. 3 Life Expectancy at Other Ages 379
8. 3. 4 Healthy or Disability-Free Life Expectancy 379
8. 3. 5 Abridged Life Tables 380
8. 3. 6 Summary 381
8. 4 Answers to Self-Assessment Exercises 381
9 Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis 385
Introduction and Learning Objectives 385
Increasing Power by Combining Studies 386
Resource Papers 387
9. 1 The Why and How of Systematic Reviews 387
9. 1. 1 Why is it Important that Reviews be Systematic? 387
9. 1. 2 Method of Systematic Review - Overview and Developing a Protocol 388
9. 1. 3 Deciding on the Research Question and Objectives for the Review 389
9. 1. 4 Defining Criteria for Inclusion and Exclusion of Studies 390
9. 1. 5 Identifying Relevant Studies 391
9. 1. 6 Assessment of Methodological Quality 396
9. 1. 7 Extracting Data 399
9. 1. 8 Describing the Results 399
9. 2 The Methodology of Meta-Analysis 402
9. 2. 1 Method of Meta-Analysis - Overview 402
9. 2. 2 Assessment of Publication Bias - the Funnel Plot 403
9. 2. 3 Heterogeneity 405
9. 2. 4 Calculating the Pooled Estimate 407
9. 2. 5 Presentation of Results: Forest Plot 408
9. 2. 6 Sensitivity Analysis 409
9. 2. 7 Statistical Software for the Conduct of Meta-Analysis 410
9. 2. 8 Another Example of the Value of Meta-Analysis - Identifying a Dangerous Treatment 411
9. 3 Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses of Observational Studies 414
9. 3. 1 Introduction 414
9. 3. 2 Why Conduct a Systematic Review of Observational Studies? 414
9. 3. 3 Approach to Meta-Analysis of Observational Studies 415
9. 3. 4 Method of Systematic Review of Observational Studies 416
9. 3. 5 Method of Meta-Analysis of Observational Studies 416
9. 4 Reporting and Publishing Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses 418
9. 5 The Cochrane Collaboration 419
9. 5. 1 Introduction 419
9. 5. 2 Cochrane Collaboration Logo 422
9. 5. 3 Collaborative Review Groups 422
9. 5. 4 Cochrane Library 422
9. 6 Answers to Self-Assessment Exercises 423
10 Prevention Strategies and Evaluation of Screening 429
Introduction and Learning Objectives 429
Resource Papers 430
10. 1 Concepts of Risk 430
10. 1. 1 Relative and Attributable Risk 430
10. 1. 2 Calculation of AR 431
10. 1. 3 Attributable Fraction (AF) for a Dichotomous Exposure 432
10. 1. 4 Attributable Fraction for Continuous and Multiple Category Exposures 434
10. 1. 5 Years of Life Lost (YLL) and Years Lived with Disability (YLD) 434
10. 1. 6 Disability-Adjusted Life Years (DALYs) 436
10. 1. 7 Burden Attributable to Specific Risk Factors 438
10. 2 Strategies of Prevention 440
10. 2. 1 The Distribution of Risk in Populations 440
10. 2. 2 High-Risk and Population Approaches to Prevention 443
10. 2. 3 Safety and the Population Strategy 446
10. 2. 4 The High-Risk and Population Strategies Revisited 447
10. 2. 5 Implications of Genomic Research for Disease Prevention 448
10. 3 Evaluation of Screening Programmes 450
10. 3. 1 Purpose of Screening 451
10. 3. 2 Criteria for Programme Evaluation 451
10. 3. 3 Assessing Validity of a Screening Test 452
10. 3. 4 Methodological Issues in Studies of Screening Programme Effectiveness 460
10. 3. 5 Are the Wilson-Jungner Criteria Relevant Today? 461
10. 4 Cohort and Period Effects 463
10. 4. 1 Analysis of Change in Risk Over Time 463
10. 4. 2 Example: Suicide Trends in UK Men and Women 464
10. 5 Answers to Self-Assessment Exercises 468
11 Probability Distributions, Hypothesis Testing, and Bayesian Methods 477
Introduction and Learning Objectives 477
Resource Papers 478
11. 1 Probability Distributions 478
11. 1. 1 Probability - A Brief Review 478
11. 1. 2 Introduction to Probability Distributions 479
11. 1. 3 Types of Probability Distribution 481
11. 1. 4 Probability Distributions: Implications for Statistical Methods 487
11. 2 Data That Do Not Fit a Probability Distribution 488
11. 2. 1 Robustness of an Hypothesis Test 488
11. 2. 2 Transforming the Data 488
11. 2. 3 Principles of Non-Parametric Hypothesis Testing 492
11. 3 Hypothesis Testing: Summary of Common Parametric and Non-Parametric Methods 493
11. 3. 1 Introduction 493
11. 3. 2 Review of Hypothesis Tests 494
11. 3. 3 Fundamentals of Hypothesis Testing 494
11. 3. 4 Summary: Stages of Hypothesis Testing 495
11. 3. 5 Comparing Two Independent Groups 496
11. 3. 6 Comparing Two Paired (or Matched) Groups 500
11. 3. 7 Testing for Association Between Two Groups 506
11. 3. 8 Comparing More Than Two Groups 508
11. 3. 9 Association Between Categorical Variables 513
11. 4 Choosing an Appropriate Hypothesis Test 517
11. 4. 1 Introduction 517
11. 4. 2 Using a Guide Table for Selecting a Hypothesis Test 517
11. 4. 3 The Problem of Multiple Significance Testing 520
11. 5 Bayesian Methods 520
11. 5. 1 Introduction: A Different Approach to Inference 520
11. 5. 2 Bayes' Theorem and Formula 521
11. 5. 3 Application and Relevance 522
11. 6 Answers to Self-Assessment Exercises 525
Bibliography 529
Index 533