"A welcome historical treatment of an issue that shows no signs of declining in importance, given the ever more public role for the Catholic and evangelical faithful in American politics." --Journal of Religion
..".a unique, very personal, and well-researched cultural analysis. A significant contribution to an ever expanding and engaging conversation." --Theological Studies
"A major achievement...the effect of this weighty, warm-hearted volume will surely be to clear the decks for quality theological action."--Books & Culture
"For a penetrating look at the faith and foolishness that has marked so much of their respective histories, both groups [Catholics and evangelicals] would do well to consult Shea's book."--National Catholic Reporter
Most often the Catholic dialogue with conservative Protestant evangelicals comes from conservative Catholics. But in this book William Shea, a first rate Catholic scholar from a liberal perspective with a broad and deep knowledge of history, American culture, and theology, makes an important and original contribution to this dialogue. With admirable fairness and even-handedness, Shea traces the historical relationship between evangelicals and Catholics in the United States. He makes a convincing case for both Christian communities to move from polemics to a mutual recognition of each other as Christian communities and to engage in a critical dialogue in which both can learn much.----Charles E. Curran, Elizabeth Scurlock University Professor of Human Values, Perkins School of Theology, Southern Methodist University
Willam M. Shea takes on a subject that has often brought out the worst in Catholics and evangelicals alike and applies to it his unique blend of wit, grace, and profound spiritual reflection. He leaves no doubt that a mature American Christianity depends on a more authentic engagement at the boundaries of the these formidable traditions. --James T. Fisher, author of Communion of Immigrants