Frederick L. Will's essay present a fresh approach that dissolves this dilemma in a way that is stimulating and liberating. -- James D. Wallace, University of Illinois, UrbanaChampaign This testament is an indispensable aid to self-understanding for American philosophers of all persuasions. -- Jim Tiles, University of Hawai'i at Manoa This is a stimulating, illuminating and rewarding work - original, important, and profound ... manifests both a superior mind and great integrity and might well prove to be a philosophical classic. -- Marcus George Singer, University of Wisconsin I have no doubt at all, that if philosophy is to prosper in the coming decades, it will have to treat with great seriousness that splendid body of philosophical writing of which the essays in this volume constitute one major part. -- Alasdair MacIntyre, research professor in philosophy, University of Notre Dame