Oddie provides an impressive technical defense of value realism. Oddie's property theory...is an important addition to work on value realism. Vaughn Huckfeldt, Journal of Value Inquiry Oddie gives you something worth thinking about on almost every page, and I am envious of his ability to put complex ideas with crystal clarity...For anyone who wants to think rigorously but creatively about the metaphysics and epistemology that moral realism needs to be plausible, this book is essential reading. Timothy Chappell, Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews a masterful book. The writing is clear and crisp and vivid ... the book has that rare quality of abounding with new ideas worth hearing Christoph Fehige, Times Literary Supplement