Situation Management for Process Control: Situation Awareness and Decision-Making for Operators in Industrial Control Rooms and Operation Centers
Operators must be able to monitor what is in their charge, to understand the information presented, and to plan and actualize needed changes. To do this successfully, they must have the necessary tools to manage situations. This book provides a broad and comprehensive approach to developing a working solution to the situation management problem, including a comprehensive way of looking at control room management and understanding the field of control room operations.
It discusses the technology and tools, as well as effective methodologies for safer and more productive control room operations, which lead to improved industrial production.
Two key discussions are how human nature (of operators) affects the ability to perform, and how to use the concept and technology of weak signals to supplement the alarm system for situation awareness.
The purpose of this book is to place a wealth of best practice information in the hands of the industrial and enterprise community. It contains a wealth of examples, alternatives, and suggestions. All control schemes, design suggestions, displays, diagrams, tables, figures, trend charts, lists, and the like refer to materials that have been designed to amplify and explain concepts and practices.
>/p>
- Enterprise management
- Operations management
- DCS application engineers including configuration and HMI
- Control room engineers and operators
- Safety and environmental engineers
- Control room designers and human factors engineers
Inhaltsverzeichnis
List of Figures xxv
List of Tables xliii
Foreword xlv
About the Author xlvii
Acknowledgments xlix
Part I Operational Integrity 1
Chapter 1 Getting Started 3
1.1 Key Concepts 4
1.2 Introduction 5
1.3 Cautions and Ground Rules 8
1.4 Audience 10
1.5 Contribution and Importance 11
1.6 Situation Management 11
1.7 Structure of Situation Management 18
1.8 Fundamental Tools for Situation Management 24
1.9 The Power of Time 30
1.10 Defensive Operating 32
1.11 Situation Management Changes the Game 35
1.12 The Overall Operational Setting 39
1.13 Standards, Guidelines, and Practices 42
1.14 Management's Role 47
1.15 The Human Operator 48
1.16 Frontline Supervisor's Role 49
1.17 How Situation Management Really Works 50
1.18 How Real Is All of This? 53
1.19 Contribution and Importance 56
1.20 Things to Keep in Mind 57
1.21 Review of Book 62
1.22 Suggestions for Using This Material 65
1.23 Actually Getting Started 69
1.24 Limitations of Situation Management 75
1.25 Close 75
1.26 Further Reading 76
Chapter 2 The Enterprise 77
2.1 Key Concepts 78
2.2 Introduction 78
2.3 Silos 82
2.4 Enterprise Capabilities 86
2.5 Short-Term versus Long-Term 89
2.6 Delegation of Responsibility 92
2.7 Operational Integrity 93
2.8 Safety 99
2.9 Responsible Engineering Authority (REA) 103
2.10 The Magic of a Control Loop 105
2.11 Selective Automation 107
2.12 The Automated Plant 112
2.13 Plant (or Enterprise) Area Model 115
2.14 Decomposition 117
2.15 Decomposition Underlying Situation Management 120
2.16 Transformational Analysis 127
2.17 Near Misses, Incidents, Accidents, and Disasters 132
2.18 Critical Failures 137
2.19 Process Hazard Management 146
2.20 Root and Other Causes 148
2.21 Layers of Protection 150
2.22 Close 151
2.23 Further Reading 151
Chapter 3 Operators 153
3.1 Key Concepts 154
3.2 Operators' Creed 155
3.3 Operators and Operations 155
3.4 Boundaries and Responsibilities 157
3.5 Operator Readiness 164
3.6 Operator Training 173
3.7 Qualified Operator 178
3.8 Operator Tools 181
3.9 Shift Handover 185
3.10 Information Content of Shift Handover 208
3.11 The Mobile Operator 210
3.12 "Long Arm" of the Operator 213
3.13 Goals, Roles, and Culture 214
3.14 Close 222
3.15 Further Reading 222
Chapter 4 High-Performance Control Rooms and Operation Centers 223
4.1 Key Concepts 224
4.2 Introduction 226
4.3 A Note about Scope 228
4.4 Control Room and Operation Center Requirements 229
4.5 The Control Room 233
4.6 Operation Centers 236
4.7 Collaboration Centers 237
4.8 Advanced Technology Control Centers 239
4.9 Design of Effective Work Spaces 241
4.10 User-Centered Design 244
4.11 Control Room Design 249
4.12 The Mobile Control Room 253
4.13 The Role of the Control Room 254
4.14 Looking to the Future 255
4.15 An Architect Weighs In 256
4.16 Close 257
Chapter 5 The Human-Machine Interface 259
5.1 Key Concepts 261
5.2 Introduction 262
5.3 Nomenclature for Display Screens and Components 263
5.4 Four Underlying Requirements for Operator Screens 265
5.5 Principles of Display Screen Design 267
5.6 Seven Principles of Workspace Design 272
5.7 The Human-Machine Interface 274
5.8 Display Screen Design 281
5.9 Navigation 298
5.10 Glyphs, Icons, Dials, Gauges, and Dashboards 305
5.11 Design Fundamentals for Icons and Dashboards 325
5.12 Trend Plots 329
5.13 Example Display Screens 334
5.14 Mass Data Displays 345
5.15 Multivariate Process Analysis 349
5.16 Displays Large and Small 353
5.17 Video Walls 365
5.18 Paper versus Electronic Screens 370
5.19 Fire, Gas, Safety Instrumented Systems, and Security Systems 377
5.20 Sound, Audio, and Video 377
5.21 Evaluating Effectiveness 380
5.22 Loss of View and Key Variables 383
5.23 Building Effective Screens 385
5.24 Further Reading 386
Part II Situation Awareness and Assessment 389
Chapter 6 Situation Awareness and Assessment 391
6.1 Key Concepts 392
6.2 Introductory Remarks 392
6.3 The Situation Management "Situation" 393
6.4 Situations to Be Aware Of 395
6.5 Strong Signals 396
6.6 Situation Management Roadmap 399
6.7 Situation Awareness Tools 401
6.8 The Psychology of Situation Awareness 402
6.9 Situation Assessment 406
6.10 Surrogate Models 407
6.11 The Four-Corners Tool 409
6.12 Close 411
6.13 Further Reading 411
Chapter 7 Awareness and Assessment Pitfalls 413
7.1 Key Concepts 415
7.2 Introduction 416
7.3 Readers' Advisory 416
7.4 Why We Make Mistakes 416
7.5 Dangers from Automation 418
7.6 Mental Models 422
7.7 Doubt 432
7.8 How We Decide 436
7.9 Biases 441
7.10 Inattention Blindness 448
7.11 Partial Information 450
7.12 Myth of Multitasking 452
7.13 Personalities 454
7.14 Geography of Thought 456
7.15 Institutional Culture versus Individual Responsibility 464
7.16 Close 469
7.17 Further Reading 470
Chapter 8 Awareness and Assessment Tools 471
8.1 Key Concepts 472
8.2 Introduction 472
8.3 Alarm System 477
8.4 Operator Ownership Transfer at Shift Change 503
8.5 Alerts, Messages, and Notifications 506
8.6 Putting It All Together 511
8.7 Making Situation Awareness Happen 512
8.8 Close 515
8.9 Further Reading 515
Chapter 9 Weak Signals 517
9.1 Key Concepts 521
9.2 Introduction 522
9.3 Weak Signals 524
9.4 Building and Displaying Weak Signals 541
9.5 Models for Weak Signal Analysis 566
9.6 Weak Signal Management 566
9.7 Digging into Weak Signals 587
9.8 Weak Signals Might Not Persist Very Long 607
9.9 Other Weak-Signal-Type Extrapolations 609
9.10 Weak Signal Templates? 611
9.11 Retrospective Weak Signals Case Study 612
9.12 Relationship between Weak Signals and Alarms 615
9.13 Relationship between Weak Signals and Critical Variables 619
9.14 Operator Weak Signals Are Tactical (Short-Term) 619
9.15 The Dependence of Weak Signal Analysis on Model Quality 622
9.16 Getting Weak Signals Working 623
9.17 Troubleshooting Guide 628
9.18 Additional Thoughts about Weak Signals 631
9.19 Close 637
9.20 Further Reading 637
Part III Situation Management 639
Chapter 10 Situation Management 641
10.1 Key Concepts 642
10.2 Introduction 643
10.3 Lessons from Air France Flight 447 647
10.4 Operations Safety Nets 649
10.5 Using Experts and Benefiting from Experience 651
10.6 Safe Conversations 652
10.7 Operational Drift 658
10.8 The Restricted Control Room 661
10.9 The Sterile Control Room 664
10.10 Lessons of Defensive Operating 665
10.11 Managing Everyday Situations 666
10.12 Doubts and Concerns 673
10.13 Delegation 674
10.14 Collaboration 675
10.15 Permission to Operate 684
10.16 Escalation 696
10.17 Escalation Teams 706
10.18 Command and Control 713
10.19 Alternate Safe Operating Modes 715
10.20 Managing Major Situations 719
10.21 Control Room Situation Codes 725
10.22 Operability Integrity Level for Online Risk Management 728
10.23 Managing Biases, Overcoming Pitfalls 730
10.24 Safety and Protective Systems 731
10.25 Key Performance Indicators 731
10.26 Miracle on the Hudson 732
10.27 Achieving Situation Management 735
10.28 Training, Practicing, Evaluating, and Mastering 739
10.29 Closing Thoughts on Situation Management 741
10.30 Further Reading 741
Appendix: Definitions of Terms, Abbreviations, and Acronyms 743
Credits 761
Index 763