How can social studies teachers include critical civic and historical content when topics like slavery and the civil rights era are deemed too "controversial" for the classroom?
This book provides a powerful, research-based framework for navigating the political and social pressures of the modern classroom. The authors argue that social studies education must center on negotiating the justice-related tensions inherent in a democracy. By framing these tensions as dilemmas for reflection rather than problems to solve, this book provides a springboard for justice-oriented social studies practices that align with the NCSS C3 Framework.
Offering indispensable guidance for both pre- and inservice teachers, the text features case studies of elementary and secondary educators addressing complex topics such as immigration, racial segregation and racism, queer equality, and the Israel-Palestine conflict. Readers will learn about the intricacies of justice-based social studies and develop the reflective habits needed to enact and sustain such practices throughout their careers.
Book Features:
- Research-Based Framework: Provides a structured approach to critical social studies and the specific tensions that arise in justice-oriented classrooms.
- Practical Case Studies: Includes narratives of teachers managing disturbing parts of history and current events, from settler colonialism to modern policy debates.
- Reflective Guidance: Offers reflection questions designed to help educators envision and build a more just and democratic world with their students.
- Activist Thinking: Advocates for an inquiry-based approach to history, civics, and the social sciences that encourages students to make change in their communities.
- Professional Alignment: Directly supports the development of transformative citizenship and reflective practice as outlined by leading educational organizations.
Inhaltsverzeichnis
Contents
1. Introduction: Social Studies for a More Just Democracy 1
Social Studies for a More Just Democracy 4
The Uncertain Nature of Social Studies for Justice and Democracy 11
Tensions in Teaching Social Studies for Justice and Democracy 12
2. Classroom Conversations: Between Listening and Speaking 17
Tension Between Listening and Speaking 18
Vignette 1: Teaching Japanese American Incarceration in an Elementary School Classroom 20
Vignette 2: Teaching the Afrikan Diaspora in a High School Classroom 22
Listening and Speaking: Reflections on Justice and Democracy 24
Wrap Up 26
3. Classroom Deliberation: Between Agreement and Disagreement 29
With Anthony Mathieu
Tension Between Agreement and Disagreement 30
Vignette 1: Teaching Political Ideologies in a High School Government Classroom 33
Vignette 2: Teaching About Historical Disinformation in a Middle School World Studies Classroom 36
Agreement and Disagreement: Reflections on Justice and Democracy 38
Wrap Up 39
4. Teaching Methods: Between Sharing and Facilitating 41
With Cristina E. Tobar
Tension Between Sharing Information and Facilitating Knowledge and Understanding 42
Vignette 1: Teaching About Movements and Debates in a High School African American Studies Classroom 44
Vignette 2: Teaching About Immigration/Migration in an Elementary School Classroom 48
Sharing and Facilitating: Reflections on Justice and Democracy 50
Wrap Up 51
5. Climate and Culture: Between Comfort and Discomfort 53
With Michaella Chung
Tension Between Comfort and Discomfort 55
Vignette 1: Teaching About Agriculture in an Elementary School Classroom 58
Vignette 2: Teaching About the Civil Rights Movement in a Middle School U.S. History Classroom 61
Comfort and Discomfort: Reflections on Justice and Democracy 64
Wrap Up 65
6. Instructional Aims: Between Reality and Hope 67
Tension Between Reality and Hope 68
Vignette 1: Teaching About Climate Change in an Elementary Classroom 70
Vignette 2: Teaching About Allyship in a Middle School Civics Classroom 72
Reality and Hope: Reflections on Justice and Democracy 75
Wrap Up 76
7. Curriculum Choices: Between Thematic and Topical 77
Tension Between Thematic and Topical 79
Vignette 1: Choosing Between Thematic and Departmental Cohesion 81
Vignette 2: Reflections on Thematically Teaching Ancient World History 83
Thematic and Topical: Reflections on Justice and Democracy 85
Wrap Up 86
8. Teacher Identities and Beliefs: Between Disclosure and Concealment 89
With Jessica Dellaquila
Tension Between Disclosure and Concealment 90
Vignette 1: To Come Out (or Not) to Students 92
Vignette 2: To Keep Up or Take Down a “Free Palestine” Poster 94
Disclosure and Concealment: Reflections on Justice and Democracy 97
Wrap Up 98
9. Professional Community: Between Respecting and Transforming (School) Culture 101
Tension Between Respecting and Transforming 102
Vignette 1: Teaching About Social Identity in a High School Government Classroom 103
Vignette 2: Teaching About the California Missions in an Elementary School Classroom 106
Respecting and Transforming (School) Culture: Reflections on Justice and Democracy 109
Wrap Up 110
10. Our Talk to Justice-Oriented Social Studies Teachers, Teacher Leaders, and Teacher Educators 111
Trilemma of Purpose, Content, and Pedagogy 111
Vignette 1: Renovating the U.S. History Curriculum in a High School 112
Vignette 2: Elevating Content in the University Social Studies Methods Course 116
Conclusion: Between Confirming and Challenging 120
Wrap Up 121
Endnotes 123
References 125
Index 143
About the Authors and Contributors 151