Can a church still claim a definite Catholic faith when a civil court appears to make doctrine negotiable? Addressed directly to the Rev. William Maskell, this theological open letter confronts the crisis created by the Privy Council's judgment in Gorham v. the Bishop of Exeter. The dispute over baptismal regeneration becomes a searching test of whether the Church of England possesses binding doctrine or merely permits competing religious opinions. Against the authority claimed by civil institutions, the argument turns to continuity: unrepealed earlier teaching, pre-Reformation Christianity and universal Catholic tradition. Ambiguity in later formularies, the letter contends, cannot quietly transform essential beliefs into optional positions. Baptism and sacramental grace provide the central ground of debate, while Scripture, the Eucharist, priesthood and ecclesiastical discipline broaden the enquiry into how doctrine is preserved, interpreted and defended. Documentary appendices and detailed footnotes give the work an evidential framework, supporting its direct challenge to the Privy Council's role in religious judgement. Its urgent questions reach beyond a single controversy: where does ecclesiastical authority reside, what duties fall upon the clergy, and how can doctrinal clarity survive the pressures of church-state conflict and liberal theology? The open-letter form keeps these issues personal and pointed, while the supporting material anchors them in the institutions and theological claims under examination. This book was out of print for decades and is now republished by Alpha Editions. It has been restored for today's and future generations. This edition is not just a reprint - it's a collector's item and a cultural treasure.