English teacher Dani Jones barely survived her last brush with murder. By the fall of 1997, she's settled back into an ordinary life of lesson plans, quiet evenings at home, and falling asleep to her boyfriend Gavin Larkhurst's late-night radio show.
Then one night, an anonymous caller whispers a name into Gavin's microphone: Clara Hammond.
In the spring of 1975, Clara left her senior prom in her gown and never came home. The police called her a runaway, and the town moved on. Twenty-two years later, someone still remembers.
Gavin does what any good DJ would do with a cold case that falls into his lap. He puts it on the air, and he tells all of Virginia Beach that his girlfriend can solve it.
He has no idea who's listening.
Clara's killer has kept the secret since prom night: patient, careful, certain no one would ever come looking. Now Dani is digging through old yearbooks and older grudges, and every night, Gavin's voice carries her questions straight to the one listener who will do anything to keep them unanswered.
With her loyal friends by her side, Dani follows Clara's trail from the boardwalk to the city's most respectable homes. But the closer she gets, the clearer it becomes that the killer's mask has fooled everyone for twenty-two years, and the face behind it may belong to someone Dani trusts.
"There are chords in the hearts of the most reckless which cannot be touched without emotion."
- Edgar Allan Poe, "The Masque of the Red Death"