Ten years ago on a cold Christmas Eve night. . . Holly and Noel Whitmore decided to throw a party at their father's secluded house on Lake Tahoe to celebrate their 18th birthday. During what should have been an innocent game of truth or dare, the night takes a horrific turn, and one of their guests ends up dead in the lake. Desperate to protect their futures, Holly, Noel, and four of their closest friends choose to bury the truth-and Corey Simmons's body-vowing never to speak of that night again. Now, a decade later, the six of them are forced to face the truth of what they did when they are lured back to the lake house for another festive celebration. Only this time, someone knows what really happened to Corey, and they want revenge. One by one, the secrets and lies between them start to unravel, and they realize that Corey's death was no accident. It was murder-and it was one of them.