"Alvin Plantinga and Michael Tooley here debate the question whether God's existence is known--or, at least, justifiably believed. As expected from two such distinguished philosophers, their discussion has the originality and intellectual weight to repay careful consideration, as much by philosophers of mind and epistemologists as by philosophers of religion." (Mind, October 2009) "The book illuminates some important issues in philosophical theology. Recommended." (CHOICE, October 2008) "I found this book strangely compelling … .Plantinga uses an ingenious new version of the Design Argument to demonstrate 'the epistemic probability' that God exists; Tooley argues that 'the fact of evil' on our world makes the existence of a benevolent God 'very unlikely.'" (Church Times, January 2009) "The present volume, by two heavyweight analytical philosophers, is rather different from the usual pattern." (The Tablet) "A very fine book, presenting arguments for and against theism and naturalism by two very distinguished philosophers. I strongly recommend it for graduate level courses." (Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews)